Forum Discussion

Hookum's avatar
Hookum
Explorer
Oct 19, 2013

Permit issue at border

I go down to San Carlos or the beach 4x a year for the past 35yrs and I thought I had my stuff together crossing the border. I was proud of myself because I have a multi-compartilzed folder for everything I bring, Kayaks, 10'inflatable, wind surfer, 14' sailbat w/trailer, SUV, m.h. air compressor, O.B motor. Whatever I bring down I have a sales receipt, title, regis. notorized statement, triple copies of every legal document, etc. I have learned over the years that they can ask for proof of ownership on anything. Including inflatable kayaks, portable generator and scuba compressor.

So today I go through KM 21, going to San Carlos, I will come down again in Nov so I asked for a 6 mo visa. He says I have to pay next door. I go next door to pay and he asks for the car title, I give him that and the title for the small sailboat trailer I am pulling. BIG mistake. He didn't ask for the trailer.

He says, were are the originals? In Tucson. He needs them. I point out that these are NOTORIZED copies and I keep the originals in a safe. That does not work for him. I tell him I don't need a permit because I am only going to San Carlos. He tells me that "Sonora only" applies only to a car and since I am pulling a itty bitty trailer, the Sonora only does not apply to me. I ask to speak to somebody else, he sends me next door to Aduana. They say I need the original titles and a photocopy that is notorized by a notary will not work.

Man o Man. I have been using these same notorized documents for 20 years and it has never caught up with me. Today was my lucky day.

What was really strange. I had stopped at the Shell station just across the border and a American from Kino stops by to talk about my trailer and sailboat. He says he has a similar one and last time he came across they would not let him in because he had a copy of the title. He had to go back to Tucson and get the original. I commented how I have never had that problem. Twenty minutes later, I suddenly have that problem and I had to go back to Tucson for the original.

I am proud of my composure. I did not raise my voice. I am not writing this from the jail house. I just starred at them with my mouth open. That is 160 miles of useless driving. I left the house at 7am, was turned around @ 10am. I got back to that same spot at 2pm and down here to S.C. at 9pm. 520 miles

What is so silly is that a color photocopy is completely indistinquishable from the original. One with a notorized stamp is more authentic. I am going to try it next time just to prove my point. This afternoon I was in no mood to talk. What I did was leave the sailboat & trailer at home, took the kayak off the trailer and put it on the car roof rack, went back down and got a 7 day free visa and I fled the scene. Now I'm just venting to you. Travelers Beware! They get us when we least expect it. Like today.

I had no clue that a car with trailer does not qualify for "no car permit needed" status in Sonora. (And I thought I knew everything.) Obviously I also had no clue about the notorized copies of titles no longer being excepted. Maybe they never did and I somehow managed to deal with folks who didn't challenge it. (The "nice people" in the permit office.)

So if you folks who understand the system better would enlighten me on were I went wrong, I would appreciate your comments. I have read Turtle Roads extensive and extremely helpful (thank you for all your work) dictionary on Mexico entry, etc but I failed to read that which pertains to my situation.

Thank you.
Norbert

PS:: In Nov. I bring down a M.h. I plan to stay in Sonora for 5 days, I will need a 10 yr permit because it is not a car. Yes?? I tow my car behind the m.h. and I need a 6 month permit for it. Yes?? I return to Tucson and come down in April with the car. Do I have to turn in the 6 mo permit when I leave in April, if I don't return before May??

What if I leave in Nov with m.h. and car and I don't come back down in the car before it expires in May. Am I obligated to send that 6 mo car permit back to KM21 before it expires?? Thanks.
  • robatthelake wrote:
    The best advice is to get The Permits before crossing the border, either by ordering on line or walking across at the actual border.

    Waiting until Km 21 is not very bright in My Humble opinion!


    Coming from Canada, through the USA and needing lots of permits, I get your point. For the past 10 years, since they implemented Sonora Travel, life was easy, I didn't need a car permit to take a car into Sonora. Only needed a free visa for a short 7 day trip. Didn't know about the towing a trailer exemption. But I do now. I was not talking about the 10yr hologram that they put on the windshield of the M.H.

    I will now make NEW color copies of the title. They will look so original "only your hairdresser can tell the difference".

    Last night, I was more venting and telling my tale of woe. More like chastizing myself for not having it all together, like I thought I did. And looking for sympathy. ha ha But that is hard to find these days. This morning I am all better and back up on top of myself.

    The border is a constant changing entity and I hadn't kept up with the changes and didn't know all the rules. That was disappointing to me and my passengers. Today, we are laughing about it, cause it all started with, "can I have a 6 month visa"?? And there it went downhill.

    Cheers
  • Canadian Rainbirds are correct. You have to have the vehicle with you when you cancel a TIP. This applies to everything that requires a TIP and the term length of the TIP does not affect this law. For 6 month TIPs this means you should turn it in EVERY TIME you come back north unless you want to wait for 4 - 6 months to get a TIP canceled. For an RV you should cancel the 10 year TIP if you even think you might want to sell/trade the vehicle before your next trip. And remember, you can only have one car TIP and one RV/Boat TIP at a time, so you will have to spend that 4-6 months outside of Mexico (or inside Mexico but without the subject vehicle).

    The 'originals only' rule has always been there, either you've just been lucky or your copies look a lot like originals.
  • I went to DMV and purchased copies of titles to the MH and toad, same as original, originals sit at the bank vault and the copies are stored in a small safe on board, they want to see the originals I pull the copies out and they are satisfied with them.

    In Latin America it is customary to have the original document and then have at least 5 or more copies all notirized, they do not trust any document that can not be veryfied by the original,I have seen documents that looked real and where actually false, some of the counterfiters are real artists.

    We caught one guy that actually painted all of the original seals by hand, he had outdated forms, that is what gave him away.

    navegator
  • The best advice is to get The Permits before crossing the border, either by ordering on line or walking across at the actual border.

    Waiting until Km 21 is not very bright in My Humble opinion!
  • You cannot just send the permit. They have to remove the hologram from the car themselves. The car MUST be present. There have been others posting here about the 6 month long or more process to cancel a permit when you no longer have the vehicle. Turn the permit in when you leave.
  • I go down to San Carlos or the beach 4x a year for the past 35yrs and I thought I had my stuff together crossing the border. I was proud of myself because I have a multi-compartilzed folder for everything I bring, Kayaks, 10'inflatable, wind surfer, 14' sailbat w/trailer, SUV, m.h. air compressor, O.B motor. Whatever I bring down I have a sales receipt, title, regis. notorized statement, triple copies of every legal document, etc. I have learned over the years that they can ask for proof of ownership on anything. Including inflatable kayaks, portable generator and scuba compressor.

    So today I go through KM 21, going to San Carlos, I will come down again in Nov so I asked for a 6 mo visa. He says I have to pay next door. I go next door to pay and he asks for the car title, I give him that and the title for the small sailboat trailer I am pulling. BIG mistake. He didn't ask for the trailer.

    He says, were are the originals? In Tucson. He needs them. I point out that these are NOTORIZED copies and I keep the originals in a safe. That does not work for him. I tell him I don't need a permit because I am only going to San Carlos. He tells me that "Sonora only" applies only to a car and since I am pulling a itty bitty trailer, the Sonora only does not apply to me. I ask to speak to somebody else, he sends me next door to Aduana. They say I need the original titles and a photocopy that is notorized by a notary will not work.

    Man o Man. I have been using these same notorized documents for 20 years and it has never caught up with me. Today was my lucky day.

    What was really strange. I had stopped at the Shell station just across the border and a American from Kino stops by to talk about my trailer and sailboat. He says he has a similar one and last time he came across they would not let him in because he had a copy of the title. He had to go back to Tucson and get the original. I commented how I have never had that problem. Twenty minutes later, I suddenly have that problem and I had to go back to Tucson for the original.

    I am proud of my composure. I did not raise my voice. I am not writing this from the jail house. I just starred at them with my mouth open. That is 160 miles of useless driving. I left the house at 7am, was turned around @ 10am. I got back to that same spot at 2pm and down here to S.C. at 9pm. 520 miles

    What is so silly is that a color photocopy is completely indistinquishable from the original. One with a notorized stamp is more authentic. I am going to try it next time just to prove my point. This afternoon I was in no mood to talk. What I did was leave the sailboat & trailer at home, took the kayak off the trailer and put it on the car roof rack, went back down and got a 7 day free visa and I fled the scene. Now I'm just venting to you. Travelers Beware! They get us when we least expect it. Like today.

    I had no clue that a car with trailer does not qualify for "no car permit needed" status in Sonora. (And I thought I knew everything.) Obviously I also had no clue about the notorized copies of titles no longer being excepted. Maybe they never did and I somehow managed to deal with folks who didn't challenge it. (The "nice people" in the permit office.)

    So if you folks who understand the system better would enlighten me on were I went wrong, I would appreciate your comments. I have read Turtle Roads extensive and extremely helpful (thank you for all your work) dictionary on Mexico entry, etc but I failed to read that which pertains to my situation.

    Thank you.
    Norbert

    PS:: In Nov. I bring down a M.h. I plan to stay in Sonora for 5 days, I will need a 10 yr permit because it is not a car. Yes?? I tow my car behind the m.h. and I need a 6 month permit for it. Yes?? I return to Tucson and come down in April with the car. Do I have to turn in the 6 mo permit when I leave in April, if I don't return before May??

    What if I leave in Nov with m.h. and car and I don't come back down in the car before it expires in May. Am I obligated to send that 6 mo car permit back to KM21 before it expires?? Thanks.



    Wow, almost seems like the juice is not worth the squeeze.