For Amish food and hospitality have any meal at Das Dutchman Essenhous in Middlebury. Here is the website www.essenhaus.com/
If it is crowded you leave your name at the front desk at the restaurant. There are two locations for eating. One is the Family Style restaurant which is normally really busy but there is another restaurant that is not as busy but where you also leave your name. Sorry can't remember which one that is.