2009 or 2010 Heartland Big Horn or 2014 Coachmen Chapparel?

We have a 2011 Bighorn 3055RL that we purchased new in 2010 and are very pleased, three years later. No major issues, just minor, very minor ones when we bought it new (had to adjust a shade, replace screws in lamp and one cabinet). You may also want to visit the Bighorn Prospective Owners Forum to ask the same question and gather more feedback.