troubledwaters wrote:
gbopp wrote:
You never see someone complaining because they have too much truck.
Actually some do. When a truck is also used as a Daily Driver (DD) and only used 10% ± as a Tow Vehicle, a 1/2 ton can make sense. A 3/4 ton can make a terrible DD for many reasons, and if its a diesel it can be even worse. So if a 1/2 ton can be used within it's ratings as a Tow Vehicle, it's a win - win when also used as a DD.
I love when this topic comes up because its gives each of us the chance to chime in and talk about how we know more than anyone else.
FWIW, I've never heard of anyone saying they had too much truck FOR THE PURPOSE WHICH THEY HAVE THE TRUCK FOR. I've heard plenty of people complain about the difficulties of DD'ing a dually. But I've never heard of anyone complain who has a short bed 3/4 ton (unless its not enough truck).
All sensible logic suggests that you should plan for the greatest need in terms of your purchases. Decisions based on the "common" need will feel quite foolish when your need is greater (even if only for a short period of time).
Over on the Grand Design forum, there is a person who came on there with a F150 EcoBoost and "1/2 ton towable" 5er...and he said that it was not enough truck. Even admitted that he was wrong and others were right. He stated that the truck had the power to do the job, but it performed poorly in cross-wind conditions.
Get the bigger truck or a smaller trailer.