Forum Discussion

pjberny5's avatar
pjberny5
Explorer
Jun 04, 2014

Extended Warranties

New to the RVing world. Recently Purchased a new Heartland Bighorn 5th wheel. Are the extended warranties worth the money for a 5th wheel or simply a pain and not worth the money.

Does Anyone have any exspierence with Good Sam Warranty Plans or with a company called Wholesale Warranties which is trying to push a warranty from FIRST EXTENDED SERVICE CORPORATION, CHICAGO, IL.

Does anyone have any expierence with FIRST EXTENDED SERVICE CORPORATION.

17 Replies

  • To buy or not to buy is a highly personal decision. I always ask one question:

    If you have a major failure, will you be able to cover the cost of the repair, or will your rig be un-usable while you continue to pay on your RV loan?

    In a FW, a refrigerator replacement is a $1500-$2000 job. That's probably one of the biggest single item repairs you could face. Of course, other multiple problems could add up to more than that. With a new rig, the chances of you recouping the cost of the policy in claims is very slim.

    EW companies are VERY profitable. That only happens because they pay out far less in claims than they take in in policy sales.

    When we had our DP, I had no prior experience with them and the thought of a $15,000 engine or tranny replacement was daunting, so we bought into a 2 year EW. After learning more about the coach and becoming more comfortable with it, we did not renew.

    Now, we just traded for a Cyclone TH (new) and have no plans to get an EW. but that's just us..... You have to decide for yourself. Eyes open and educate yourself on these policies. READ & UNDERSTAND THE FINE PRINT!
  • If you never heard of the company...would you trust buying your health insurance from them? Same would apply to an extended warranty...What makes you think you will need it?

    B.O.
  • Go to www.rv-dreams.com there is a good explanation regarding pros & cons of extended warranties.
  • If not legally required most often the benefits to the seller of the insurance is greater than to the buyer of the insurance on average or they would not sell it. :)

    People have different emotional needs so the answer can vary greatly on this question.

    We wind up fixing things ourselves so often this can of insurance does not work well for us. I do buy it on some Harbor Freight electronic items if the price is right but not it if cost more than $20.
  • On a new rig why would you purchase a warranty? The new rig should come with a factory warranty. Maybe after the manufactures warranty expires I would look at it again. But on a new rig everything should be covered for a least a year or two. Why pay for double coverage? All you are doing is giving the dealership a bigger profit on the sale and in my opinion you gain nothing. If you are talking about a used rig then I would consider it.