Gooseneck Question

I do believe there's a huge difference in payload weight and hitch weight ratings on the pictures old biscuit posted but I'm still not for g-neck adaptors on a 5er. Just the duallys on the g-neck trailer are a dead giveaway it's not even close to a fair comparison. I did serious damage to one of my 5ers with a g-neck. The adaptor doubled the distance the front of the frame flexed and it tore up the siding and wall paneling. But... if it doesn't have any damage by now it might be worth a chance and I'd get that adaptor off ASAP. Hopefully your friend will level with you if he knows of any damage. Craig

Dtank wrote:

agesilaus wrote:


But ask your self this, how many semis have you seen using a gooseneck?

The furnished advice was good, however......
it should have *not* have included this (useless) trivial question.

Semis (tractor/trailers) use a hitch that does not articulate side to side.
It will do more damage to a 5th wheel (RV) trailer than a gooseneck.
That's why the first thing to go on an HDT conversion for RV 5h wheel towing is the commercial hitch on the tractor.

And the damage is where?? I've owned RV 5th wheel hitches for 26 yrs., none with side pivot and never had an issue. And no 5th wheel manufacturer has a disclaimer stating that their units can only be used with side pivot hitches. Also if this was a serious issue, then the semis would have side pivot hitches as well to prolong the life of those aluminum box trailers. Got any details?

Dtank wrote:


However, many construction folks *do* successfully use gooseneck hitches to pull trailers with heavy construction equipment.

.

Heck yeah........see lots of that.
But those trailers have been gooseneck trailers....not 5th wheel
Gooseneck trailers are designed to carry HEAVY Loads

5th wheel........sometimes can't even carry designed loads

5th wheel frame structure (Lippert design)


Gooseneck frame structure



BIG Difference in design due to stresses exerted at hitch point

agesilaus wrote:


But ask your self this, how many semis have you seen using a gooseneck?

The furnished advice was good, however......
it should have *not* have included this (useless) trivial question.

Semis (tractor/trailers) use a hitch that does not articulate side to side.
It will do more damage to a 5th wheel (RV) trailer than a gooseneck.
That's why the first thing to go on an HDT conversion for RV 5h wheel towing is the commercial hitch on the tractor.

However, many construction folks *do* successfully use gooseneck hitches to pull trailers with heavy construction equipment.

.

Interesting read. I've been using gooseneck adapters for 20 years because I'm always pulling large trailers that have gooseneck hitches. My son just bought a new 5'er from Camping World and they added a gooseneck adapter without a warning on warranty coverage. Will have to pursue this further. Jerry.

I did read it and don't see the problem. It's no different than any other warranty. However, for those who need justification for not considering the Andersen, they can use the warranty.

rskeans wrote:

Whether it was approved or not approved is in-material. ... Further, to give comfort to those concerned, Andersen provides a $5M protection warranty.

They do offer that warranty, and if you read it there is a very easy out for them in it. If you are the guy caught between them and Lippert, you will have a lot of money out to get your issue fixed, and/or a very long wait in litigation to get it settled.

Or you can avoid the possibility in the first place.

ramgunner wrote:

hbillsmith wrote:
Andersen Ultimate Fifthwheel Hitch for gooseneck trucks. Approved by Grand Design and Open Range.

The Andersen Ultimate is NOT approved by Grand Design. They are following the recommendation of Lippert that it is NOT approved. You can find out more by contacting them directly or checking out the Grand Design Owners Forum.

Whether it was approved or not approved is in-material. There has never been a failure to a frame due to the Andersen. Further, to give comfort to those concerned, Andersen provides a $5M protection warranty. Refer to their web site, bottom PDF.
http://www.andersenhitches.com/Catalog/gooseneck-mount--ultimate-5th-wheel-connection.aspx

hbillsmith wrote:
Andersen Ultimate Fifthwheel Hitch for gooseneck trucks. Approved by Grand Design and Open Range.

The Andersen Ultimate is NOT approved by Grand Design. They are following the recommendation of Lippert that it is NOT approved. You can find out more by contacting them directly or checking out the Grand Design Owners Forum.

Hey all--new here. Been researching the Andersen Ultimate, especially since they are made here in my hometown. Granted, my 5ver is not especially long, but I'm sold on the Andersen. I found this on their website for those that are worried about voided warranties from their 5ver manufacturer. I've been using a regular plate because of the horror stories on goosenecks, but I'm going to go with Andersen. I'm not one that can lift big plates in and out of the bed of my truck and this is another added benefit of the Andersen to me--having my whole bed available if I need it. I plan to be RVing fulltime starting in mid-July so I'll let you all know how it goes.

http://www.andersenhitches.com/uploads/Supplemental%20Warranty%20-%20Ultimate%202015.pdf