I personally would never purchase any thing built by coachman no matter how beautiful they look. I have known so many who purchased their products and had leaks and more leaks. One family had the side wall come loose from the frame. The wife was riding in the passenger seat and looked down and could see the road going by under her feet. This was in the first month of owning the brand new rig.....Others we have known have had vent leaks and window leaks on their units that had to be repeatedly repaired. So from the experiences of our former club members I would say go with the Cedar Creek.....