Forum Discussion

way2roll's avatar
way2roll
Navigator III
Jun 19, 2020

The more I learn, the more I realize what I don't know

So still on the fence about a FW vs MH and shopping continues. having owned 2 Class A's that's my comfort zone. But Since I need a new truck and FW's have a lot more space for the buck, I am leaning that way. However, the more I shop and learn, the more I realize I how much more I need to learn. You folks have graciously answered all my questions so far, but I have more.

First, one of the biggest hangups is frankly intimidation. Backing a FW into a tight camp site is intimidating. So is fueling up. Sure practice, practice etc. I've never really been great at backing trailers or boats. Now either of my Class A's I could put within inches of where I wanted to be. Will practice really overcome this - maybe some of you had this same feeling?

In shopping brands I have NO CLUE, what I am looking at in terms of brand hierarchy. I can tell you down to the nuts and bolts of every newer Class A out there but literally know nothing of FW's. Our budget is going to put us at 40-50k. No idea what brands/features or pitfalls to look for in that range. I also know some of this is clouded in personal opinion- and that's Ok. Opinions come from experience.

Generators - do most FW's really have no generator? Seems that way in my price range. We used our Genset a lot in our MH but of course we were in it at the time.

Stopping and using things - on long travel days I assume you can use the FW for a snack/lunch/bathroom etc. I assume either elec or lp fridge can stay on during travel, but many floorplans don't allow access to the fridge with slides in. Do you bump them out at a rest stop? I assume AC is out of the question. If you wanted to overnight and dry camp, seems without a generator you have pretty limited power via batts right? Provided you are fairly level, can you use the FW - slides out etc - , while hooked up to the truck?

Build quality - I was told (don't shoot the messenger) that despite price range, most FW's are built pretty much the same. That most of the extra price is in better appointments (cabinets, furniture, trim - this is largely true for MH's). I did see that some of the frames and suspension might be beefier on bigger ones. I was also told that tires on a cheaper FW can only last 5-10k miles? Is this true?

Maintenance - I don't want to assume, but seems like a FW is a lot less maintenance than a MH - mainly there is no engine, genset or transmission. Just regular maintenance - seals, plumbing, roof, batts etc. Am I right? I see a lot of noise about packing bearings etc, no clue what that's about.

Hooking up - again, looks intimidating. I see some come with electric, adjustable pins, sliding receivers, auto leveling to help some of this. But I wouldn't know a good FW receiver from a stick. Just how hard is hooking up? What does a decent receiver cost?

Seems like FW's in my price range don't come with a lot. They may have W/D hookups, but you have to buy the appliances. You have to buy the TV's, solar prep but no panels, etc. Just seems like there is more to buy to "finish" out the camper than a MH. Maybe it's just my price range and perhaps that's why my price range exists.

Pricing, I know what the %off MSRP is on MH's. It usually hovers around 26-30%. Does the same math apply for FW's. Will they throw in a hitch, or W/D, extras. I know this is negotiation (we are looking at new) but generally speaking.

As always I am probably over thinking most of this, but I want to have almost zero reliance on a salesmen. They have an agenda. I would like to actually know what I am talking about.

Thanks again for all your help in schooling me. I remember taking 5 years to pick our first MH. I really want to make a decision by fall on this one.

33 Replies

  • Backing a FW into a tight camp site is intimidating.

    I've found it's not so much getting the 5er in there, but making sure the front end swing of the truck doesn't take out campground signs, posts, or shrubs.

    Our budget is going to put us at 40-50k.

    That's not a big budget for a good quality unit, and quality usually comes with price. You could double that - but isn't that often how it works out?

    Generators - do most FW's really have no generator?

    No, they usually don't, but I'm sure it's an option in many.

    Build quality - I was told (don't shoot the messenger) that despite price range, most FW's are built pretty much the same.

    No, I don't agree with that. The 'lite' models will be pretty poor build quality.
  • If you can put a motorhome within inches after practicing, you will be able to do the same with a FW after practice. If you have a spotter and a camera that always helps. I used to just get out, look, then back a few inches and repeat. Hooking up is fairly easy too. I think the main difference is with a motorhome you can get out of bed and start driving. That's good if there is an emergency or raining. In a FW you'd have to get out and walk to the truck to drive off. Floor plans; you are right about wanting to get to the fridge and bathroom during a quick stop at a rest area. I have two smaller Honda generators. I thought about having a big generator in the FW compartment but I can use the Honda's at home too. I just haul them in the bed or my truck and when we stop at night I run the cord to them and run them all night if I want. Some rigs can have a generator compartment with a remote start. While driving you could start your generator to run the AC for an hour before stopping and when you stop the rig will be cool. Auto leveling is a must luxury! push a button after unhooking and wait. One of the best hitches is BW; easy to use but heavy if/when you want to take it out of the truck bed. But worth it in my opinion. Not sure what the cost is because when I bought my FW, the dealer included it. As to quality, there are several well made FW's out there. But, the general RV industry uses the same ingredients (fridge, AC, etc). Maintenance is important as you probably know. FW vs Motorhome; from what Ive seen, a Motorhome you would probably need to tow a small car to get around after you stop for a while. FW, you just unhook the truck. When I looked at buying my FW, I searched online and found a dealer in Texas and drove from CA to get it. Well worth it since I have relatives there I could visit. The price and service was excellent. Tires: on a FW you will want to quickly upgrade to a higher load rated tire. The ones the manufacturers put on are the lowest bid and cheapest. They don't last and will blowout and damage your trailer's siding. Good luck, I hope I answered some of your questions.
  • The reason I abandoned towing is, as I got older, my appreciation for just pulling into a spot and only have to do my hookups and push a levelling button increased a lot! Most of the time spaces are not long enough to stay connected so you have no choice but to immediately unhitch. If the weather is bad, that's something that you can't put off until the rain stops like just temporarily "boondocking" with your tanks, propane, and batteries until the cloud passes. I should also add we no longer drag a toad as that caused the same issues. Most all the "destination" RV places with things to do have an Enterprise car rental close by. Not having anything behind us makes parking and just general navigation in tight areas so much easier. One example is most Cracker Barrel restaurants have dedicated RV parking but in most locations they just designated two end to end spots as the "RV" spot. Fine for a motorhome or average bumper pull TT but with a 5th wheel you won't be eating there. As a motorhome owner I'm sure you reached the level of proficiency where you were never fearful of driving it around a corner where if you were pulling something, the need to back up if you encountered something that you could not get by would have cause a BIG problem.