Forum Discussion

Almot's avatar
Almot
Explorer III
Dec 09, 2017

When do you empty black tank on hookup?

Evenings, mornings, twice a day, every 2 days, - or just leave the shutter to sewer permanently open?

Sewer is prehistorical, Mexican style - hole in the ground with cement lid.
As I see it - leaving the shutter open, fumes from sewer will flow easily into tank. Besides, potential risk of "poop pyramid" build-up in a dry tank. One person trailer, didn't happen so far, but you never know...

There is no 15-20 gallons of water added after emptying it, like some people recommend - what water in desert, I have to pay for water truck to come once in a while.

I've come to emptying it in the morning and then in the evening. So solids are diluted with liquids and when shutter opens, it all runs happily down the pipe. Then close the shutter again. On a calm day I can smell it for a few minutes from sewer vent pipe 15 ft away, after emptying. That vent pipe (not my trailer tank vent) is 1ft above the ground. Luckily, it's just me on this sewer, so everything filters down into sand shortly after.

Oh yeah, and making a cross ;) of 2 strips of toilet paper in the bowl works like a charm - solids slip down with the paper, otherwise it sticks to this un-ergonomic plastic bowl.
  • Almot wrote:
    One person in a trailer. It will be weekS before I empty it when full. Brewing and smelling into trailer through the bowl all this time. 77-80 in November-December, this brewery just loves it when it's warm.

    Emptying when 3/4 - maybe. It could still be a week or more.

    Yes, grey tank is always open, this is not a problem.


    There should be NO odors coming thru toilet bowl. Water should be staying in bowl which provides a vapor barrier

    Grey being open all the time could very well be your odors issue.
    Under bathroom sink is probably an Air Admittance Valve (allows air into sink drain line so 'P' trap doesn't get sucked dry)
    Most are cheap flapper style that fatigues and then stays open....that allows grey tank stink back into RV

    Grey drain valve always open allow liquids to flow out as they flow in so debris/stuff (body oils, hair, sloughed skin, cooking greases/oils, food particles etc) gets left behind-accumulates, dries out and STINKS

    Drain WASTE tanks when FULL for that WHOOSH affect.
    Water is heavy and the volume carries 'stuff' out

    A fast moving river can move boulders
    A slow trickle in a creek can't even budge a pepple
  • Almot's avatar
    Almot
    Explorer III
    One person in a trailer. It will be weekS before I empty it when full. Brewing and smelling into trailer through the bowl all this time. 77-80 in November-December, this brewery just loves it when it's warm.

    Emptying when 3/4 - maybe. It could still be a week or more.

    Yes, grey tank is always open, this is not a problem.
  • The common recommendation is to empty the black tank when it's at least 3/4 full to ensure a good "flush" action. The grey tank can be left open, although in your case that may cause some odor issues. Grey tank waste can smell as bad or worse than the back tank sometimes.
  • Empty the tank when it gets full. Then, let it fill up again. Repeat.