Forum Discussion

onrecess's avatar
onrecess
Explorer
Jun 10, 2017

NEVER call for a tire- RIP OFF

Last weekend we were camping in Okeechobee, FL. Sunday morning I saw my rear inner dual was flat. I mean one side of tire missing, (had driven there in driving rainstorm.) I called good Sam. I've had tires brought out before, and it cost $500 or so. Been a couple of years at least. Being Sunday, all tire stores were closed.
The girl got back to me with a price of $750. This seemed, um, excessive.
I said give me a while to decide. I called locally to see if I could do it cheaper. There was 2 local companies on the little KOA campground map ads. I call one, told him the cafe were I was sitting, and the guy says I already called. I said no, and he said some roadside assistance company I never heard of (I guess Good Sam uses someone else for these calls?) I said $750 was too much. He was a LITTLE surprised. The actual total, for the Goodyear 245 70R 19.5, was a hair under $500. When he was fixing it, he said he knew, when they said the caller changed his mind, that they had tried to rip me off.
I paid $500, INCLUDING the $95 roadside emergency charge.
Good Sam had DOUBLED the tire price.
If you have no spare, save yourself $250 and just call the local guy. It will be the same guy, the same tire, but no $250 upcharge.
Funny, I thought I PAID Good Sam yearly (for 12 years) and THAT was their profit. It isn't. Sure, I'll call for towing or break downs, but never for a tire.

54 Replies

  • Obviously what happened was a systemic, procedural practice. The GS employee didn't make it up on the spot.
    How many other times does GS mark up covered service?
  • Thank you for the post onrecess,
    I apologize for your experience with roadside. Please send me a private message with your member number and contact info and I'll contact you.

    Thank you,
    Zach

About Customer Support

Our Customer Service team is available to assist you any time between 6am-10pm MST. Ask a question about your account, recent order, and more.2,673 PostsLatest Activity: Aug 15, 2025