We also received an offer by mail very early (could have been as far as 6 mo before renewal) and I pitched it in the trash. Now that our membership is expiring at the end of the month, we have received no further renewal offer. I do know that I can renew online at anytime, however the timing of the offers seems confusing. I am not too concerned though as we probably won't renew as we have not used many Good Sam Park discounts as we workamp and sit 4-6 months at a time in one place. When we are on the road traveling more we would then reconsider it.