You are comparing a Newell with no slide outs, which is a highline motor home, to middle of the product line rigs with slideouts.
A more fair comparison would be a Monaco Signature or Country Coach Affinity compared to the Newell. Then the differences could be more subjective.
The Camelot and Scepter would compare favorably to the Country Coach Allure or Intrigue.
With your condition caveats, yes, the four coaches could provide the same service.
Which one will be cheaper will be the luck of the draw, but I would bet on the Foretravel. Given the original cost of the Newell it is possible that the original owner had additional money to spend on maintenance.
However, if you decided you needed the room provided by slide outs, selling the Newell and buying another rig could be the more expensive route?
JMHO
Ooops, my bad! The write up states two slides.
