Forum Discussion

LoveTheWest's avatar
LoveTheWest
Explorer
Oct 30, 2018

2019 Gas or Diesel ?

I was wondering how the 2019 Ford diesel stacks up.

OR... should I stick with a gas engine.
My driving will be about 50/50 city driving / out in the country driving.

Thanks for your comments.

35 Replies

  • Ralph Cramden wrote:
    A prediction. People on these boards who have diesel will say "get a diesel", people with a gasser will say "get a gasser".


    I have another prediction, someone is going to say Ralph missed a few things, like longevity and dependability of a diesel. Paint the whole picture, sure $$$ is a part of it.
  • Are you talking about the 1/2 ton diesel?

    Assuming the tow/haul ratings are good, it's basically a calculation of miles driven vs MPG:

    - What is the up front cost to buy the diesel vs the gas?
    - How many miles do you drive per year?
    - Take the miles driven and divide by the MPG for each engine type then multiply by the cost per gallon to get the annual fuel cost for each engine type.
    - Now it's easy to estimate how many years it will take to recoup the up front cost of the diesel.
    - At this point, it's probably too early to know if there will be any impact on resale value.

    Personally, I would give it a year or two before buying a new engine design, so they can work out the kinks.
  • Depends on the job which tool you’ll want. Towing light and running around town, gas. Heavy towing, diesel. I’ve had both gas and diesel towing TT and 5th wheel. I now have a diesel 3500 and use it for every day driving too. Love it
  • LoveTheWest wrote:
    I was wondering how the 2019 Ford diesel stacks up.

    OR... should I stick with a gas engine.

    LOL, Now look what you have done!

    Do the math.

    Diesel is roughly a $9K option.
    Diesel is $0.54 more per gallon US average, more in some states like here in PA @ $0.64 more per gallon.

    A prediction. People on these boards who have diesel will say "get a diesel", people with a gasser will say "get a gasser".

    The thread will descend into chaos in short order and most likely be locked down LOL.