Forum Discussion

n4hwl's avatar
n4hwl
Explorer
Feb 21, 2016

40 ft compared to 45 ft

I have a 40 foot motorhome now. I am comfortable driving it. We do visit lots of state and federal campgrounds now. We often have to take special precautions and planning to be sure that this will fit.

Driving is not my concern.
I would like to talk to those that have gone from a 36 or 40 ft motorhome up to a 45 foot one. Compare please. Driving, parking handling? Increased, if any, difficulty in finding accommodation when traveling. I tend to want to stay with the length I have now but there sure are some tempting 45 footers out there. Thanks in advance for your suggestions.

Ken
  • Not much difference other than to remember the extra four or five feet is all in the tail (aft of the dually wheels) so the tail swing is greater.
  • We went from 42 to 45. Honestly, I thought 3 ft. wouldn't make a difference but it does. We now fit tight in most places where we would have fit OK with the previous coach. 3 ft. is 3 ft. LOL!

    I have to be more careful making tight turns, lifting the tag does help.

    We are 45' 8" from bumper to bumper. Then, with the Blue Ox tow bar attached to the back, I barely fit in our storage garage.



    MM.
  • msmith1199 wrote:
    I have not done it and I can't speak for the laws in every state, but I would never get anything bigger than a 40' myself only because you add a lot of restrictions. In California it requires a special drivers license and then there are many road restrictions. For example most of Highway 1 has a 40 foot max limit. And the many different cities have ordinances that place restrictions on vehicles over 40 feet and where they can and can't drive.

    I know quite a few people on here have them and love them and that's great for them. I just don't want the extra hassle for the extra five feet. Not to mention all the things you brought up about that many more camp grounds you can't get into.


    I haven't seen any more issues with my 43' than I did with the 40'. There is a possibility that a lot of the issues you mention may not be present if one is not driving in CA....which I avoid like the plaque....no offense but it's not the most user friendly state to visit.

    Please correct me if I'm wrong but isn't the drivers license issue only for CA residents. I've never heard of anyone having an issue if they are licensed in another state.
  • Ivylog's avatar
    Ivylog
    Explorer III
    I started with a used 36' DP because of posts on here that 36' was the max for NP, SP, USFS, ....... did not take long to learn that was not true so traded for a 40' and 12 years ago 42' plus I built my MH bay long enough for 45'. In Yellowstone it's easy to make a 42' become a 40' for their max length sites:W... would be harder to make a 45' into a 40'.

    In the East and in CA it's a bigger problem finding Public CG sites big enough (not impossible) and in the West it's much easier. My 42' has a slightly better turning radius than a non tag 40' as the drive axle wheelbase is shorter... not so for 45'. It is amazing how much better a tag axle coach handles even though my 40' was a RR8R Beaver. There is a lot of truth that once you have a tag, you will not go back plus having 9000+ lbs of CCC makes it too easy to keep too much stuff. If I had to replace this MH I'd probably go with a 44 or 45'.
  • With a 40' MH you will, most likely have a single rear axle. 45' gives a tag with some loss of storage space, extra tires to buy, improved stability & weight carrying capacity. I wouldn't worry about CA restrictions. Your driver's license is good in all states and you probably have a toad for side trips.
  • I have not done it and I can't speak for the laws in every state, but I would never get anything bigger than a 40' myself only because you add a lot of restrictions. In California it requires a special drivers license and then there are many road restrictions. For example most of Highway 1 has a 40 foot max limit. And the many different cities have ordinances that place restrictions on vehicles over 40 feet and where they can and can't drive.

    I know quite a few people on here have them and love them and that's great for them. I just don't want the extra hassle for the extra five feet. Not to mention all the things you brought up about that many more camp grounds you can't get into.