Forum Discussion

OldSalt92's avatar
OldSalt92
Explorer
Apr 21, 2018

Class A vs. Super C

My wife has become convinced a Super C is the best choice for a Diesel motor home due to safety. I've also read concerns about fires in the rear of Diesel Pushers. I'd like to stay about 35' for Nat'l and state parks, but floor plan preferences push me toward 37 or 38 feet. Will primarily be traveling Nat'l Parks of the west,with some short stays, and looking at an RV trip to Alaska. Also, have read International Durastar diesel has lots of maintenance problems. And what about noise when accelerating or climbing a grade from a front diesel? One thing I don't like about Gassers.

14 Replies

  • We are looking at upgrading to a 45' DP however have no plans to take it north to Alaska. Lived there for 25 years, visited again in 2016 towing a 31' 5'er and finding places that will handle that rig was a challenge up north. Provincial CG's are not set up for longer RV's. Plus for more money you get less amenities at your sites. Yukon Provincial Parks provide free firewood. Basically a place to park for the night for what you would pay for a decent full service RV site in the lower 48 state. BUT, the scenery and experience is worth the trip.

    Today's Class A coaches are going to all electric. No propane heat, cooking, ovens etc. At least that is what we are finding for our next RV. Either shore power or run the Cummins/ONAN generator.
  • Almost invariably when someone post a picture or video of an RV on fire on the highway it is the rear of a class A. Although no doubt that number vs the actual number on the road is very small.
  • As a class A owner, and a bus driver who drives a Deisel bus with the super 'C' nose, I really don't think there'll be any difference between the engine being up front with you, (other than the engine noise) or in back, as far as performance. MY biggest issue with my class A, is the fact that theres only one door, and no other way out, except through the window.

    When I first purchased my DP, I was driving to the dealer up the NY thruway, to get my punch list taken care of. Looking out the mirror, I saw that one of my basement doors was open. I pulled off to the right, as far off the road as I could, and couldn't get out because of the guardrail. I ended up having to pull off on the left side, exit the vehicle with left lane traffic flying past me, and re enter traffic from the left hand lane....it seems none of the class a's come with driver doors anymore.