landyacht318 wrote:
Determining when an AGM battery is full, requires an ammeter, or a amp hour counting battery monitor.
HOld long absorption stage is to be held, is highly dependent of state of charge on the battery, how long since its last full recharge, the overall health of the battery, and temperature.
LifeLine AGM says 20 amps per 100AH minimum when deeply cycled. Hold 14.4v until amps taper to 0.5amps for a 100AH battery, and then the battery can be considered fully charged
I've seen my 90AH Northstar AGM taper to 0.42 amps at 14.46v in 3 hours, I've also seen it take 11 hours. 6 of those last ones at 1 amp or less.
Far too many people think that once a charging source drops to float voltage, that this means the battery is fully charged. IT DOES NOT mean this, only that absorption voltage was held as long as it was programmed to do so.
6 more hours might be required at absorption voltage before amps taper to 0.5% of capacity at absorption voltage.
The less healthy the battery, the longer it takes to reach this threshold where the AGM battery can be considered fully charged.
Get an ammeter and see what the battery is accepting at absorption voltage, otherwise you are basically completely blind and simply guessing as to AGM state of charge.
I would agree with most of this with a couple of additions.
An ammeter will tell you when the batteries are full, but a monitor that counts amp hours and goes by them to determine state of charge will not be accurate on the recharge side of the cycle because they can't accurately know the charge efficiency. Charge efficiency varies by battery, depth of discharge, and even where you are in the charge cycle, so it is nearly impossible to guess or calculate it precisely.
That said, most good monitors calculate the charged "indicator" separately from the amp hour count or state of charge percent. For instance, on a Trimetric you program in the voltages for charging and the amps you need to reach to be fully charged. When you get there it lights the fully charged light. The amp hours returned can be either over or under the amount you actually used depending on how the charge efficiency setting matched that particular charge cycle. Same with state of charge display, could be either way. Once you start a discharge cycle without charge voltage, the Trimetric will reset the amp hour counter to zero and the state of charge to 100%, so will be accurate on the discharge cycle.
The .5% that Lifeline states as full is pretty generic to cover new and old batteries, and you can go lower on new ones very easily. Our new ones will go to .2%. It is also voltage influenced so it will be higher if you go to high end of the charge range at 14.6v. It takes a long time to get there.
If you do stop at .5%, or any amount above the actual minimum, the charge will finish off on float of 13.3v on Lifelines, if you have the time. After going to our .2% at absorption we show .1 amp 13.3v float. After a week of float it is under .01 amps. This is on 440ah of battery bank. This would say that even if you take your batteries to the lowest amp in reading, they probably also can benefit from continued float rather than taking them off charge.
All of this gets pretty complex to accurately control when you have 3 charging systems (shore, solar, engine alternator), if you are trying to always get your batteries full when actually camping, driving, on and off shore power, etc, especially since you don't overcharge either. The good thing is that you can be fine if you get the batteries totally full every 5-10 charge cycles.