We use Progressive and had a roadside claim that was handled great just this past weekend. We called a couple of carriers when we bought ours last year and Progressive had the best price for the same amount of coverage. We use Safeco on our cars for the same reason. Since ours will be up in a month or so, I think I'll give GEICO a call. I don't think we tried them because they were always way more than everybody else on cars (despite the catchy commercials - miss the cavemen).