Appreciate all the responses. I am currently with National General and have received quotes from Progressive and Auto Owners.
Looks like I will be moving to Auto Owners as they can save me at least 33% from the current National General quote (which I actually called them directly - they saved me about $200 from the independent insurance agent but still looking at a large increase).
The Auto Owners quote will actually decrease my insurance from last year.
As they say, it pays to call around and not just renew up every year. If National General had been reasonable with a small increase I would still be their customer, now I am not and will save money!
Hope we call can roam the country freely soon! Stay safe and healthy!