Forum Discussion

nehuge's avatar
nehuge
Explorer
Apr 11, 2018

Need advice, in a lot of trouble

Hi all, my last posting was about my fridge but now I'm on to something much worse.

We are at a resort where its all white concrete that you park on. The owners are very specific about getting stains on the concrete, as this is a new park.

I had a mobile mechanic, rated pretty well online to come out and do a transmission flush. I had no leaks, gasket and pan were as dry as a bone, and when I get home........OH NO.

I guess my wife (since she was home in the vehicle and I had gone to work) had said that during the refilling after the pan was off, they found it to be leaking. So they put in another gasket and did it again. Checked it, then left. I get home and I have a humongous puddle of transmission fluid under the vehicle. It is everywhere.

Now mind you, I had put down humongous tarps that are as wide as the vehicle, and take up about 1/4 of its length each under there, thinking it's just an added measure, it'll catch some single drips if there are any.

Here's the clincher. The mechanic indicated that "these pans as they go off and on during maintenance over the years can get 'sprung' or bent. It'll need a new pan. We put on two different new gaskets and if its still doing it, it needs a new pan. Do you want to pick one up or shall I?"

So here's the question. The thing was fine until they touched it. Now he's telling me I should buy the pan and not HIM? He said if I don't buy the pan, he won't do the job.

I haven't experienced anything like this before, so not that I"m asking legal advice but more of the opinion of does he pay for it or me? I mean it was find before they touched it. Isn't it on them???

35 Replies

  • I'm sorry for your headache. My first assumption is you asked this RV Resort for permission to have your coach serviced at the site and they granted permission. So is it possible they can weigh in with this idiot tech's employer to make this right? I'm just wondering if the RV Resort might be capable of threatening their future business more than you alone.
  • The idiot overtorqued the pan bolts. Its all too common of an occurance. You will need to drop the pan and place it gasket side down on a surface plate to see how warped it is.
  • The pan didn't get bent while it was bolted in place, it got bent when he prayed it off. If not bent too bad it can be straightened, and if bent to badly I wonder what else he did wrong.
  • First, in my opinion trans flushes are a scam usually done by the drive thru oil change people. Second, I've never heard of a pan warping like that. Sounds more like a bad gasket job or he left some of the old gasket in place. There are sealers that can be put on gaskets to help it seal properly if needed.

    I'm not a mechanic, just have done a lot of my own work. Others will chime in I'm sure. Take it to a real transmission shop for repair.