Forum Discussion

SJ_Eagle's avatar
SJ_Eagle
Explorer
Apr 29, 2017

Need New House Batteries - HELP!

Hello all, I could sure use some help and guidance from the experts! I'll do my best to keep this short and really appreciate you taking the time to read about my dilemma.

I have a 2005 American Eagle 40J and my batteries are toasted after 2.5 years. That being said I also need to explain that we had a bad inverter motherboard which was likely the culprit. Before finding out about the motherboard, we had two large solar panels installed because we also do a lot of dry camping.

I currently have 4 Interstate 6v Deep Cycle, 232ah batteries that we purchased in late 2014.

After installing the solar I thought our issues would be solved but my volts seem to follow the sun going down, to around 12.2, from a full 14.7 during the day. Is this normal? Shouldn't they remain higher? We run our inverter during the night for a sleeping machine and in the morning we're typically around 11.8v and have to fire up the generator to get things moving again. So, that's a long way of saying I think my batteries aren't holding a charge. I check the batteries fairly often and make sure they have enough water.

On to the question and request - I watch the RV Geeks pretty often and noticed they upgraded to the Lifeline AGM. I can't really see spending $1600 on 4 house batteries and I know there are lots of schools of thought out there but, what's a good, maintenance FREE battery that will hold a charge and last, without breaking the bank? Lifeline, Trojan, Costco, Duracell?

Deeply appreciate your feedback!

Steve

55 Replies

  • MountainAir05 wrote:
    SJ Eagle wrote:
    Thanks for the advice! Never heard of that. So in your opinion, flooded are better than gel? Again, I know about as much about batteries as I do rocket science. Are AGM considered Gell batteries?


    No AGM are not gel and they last a lot longer and charge different. I have several AGM and they are 5 years old and show no sign of issues. Yes they are more money for them than lead acid. but no water to add and just keep them clean and charged with the proper charger.


    Thanks for that! I like the idea of no watering and I'm certainly willing to pay a little more for quality, lasting batteries. So, brand suggestion and average price? Also, does the AH matter? Looking at a lot of battery types and they seem to be all over the board, from 100AH to 400AH. Seeing that I have 4, and a 40ft bus that we use a lot in dry camping areas, what's the best AH to look for, and brand. Thank you again!!
    Anyone else? Love the education!
    Steve
  • SJ Eagle wrote:
    Thanks for the advice! Never heard of that. So in your opinion, flooded are better than gel? Again, I know about as much about batteries as I do rocket science. Are AGM considered Gell batteries?


    No AGM are not gel and they last a lot longer and charge different. I have several AGM and they are 5 years old and show no sign of issues. Yes they are more money for them than lead acid. but no water to add and just keep them clean and charged with the proper charger.
  • I was in Costco yesterday and Interstate 6 volt flooded batteries were around $100. You can buy a lot of those for $1600.

    I use four 12 volt interstate batteries and never had a problem (Off line).
    But thats me.
  • Thanks for the advice! Never heard of that. So in your opinion, flooded are better than gel? Again, I know about as much about batteries as I do rocket science. Are AGM considered Gell batteries?
  • Get flooded batteries and get an automatic watering system. These systems make is VERY simple to keep them topped off and you get a much better bang for the buck with flooded batteries.