The latches pictured above came standard on our 2016 Journey. They failed within 60 days. The other one pictured would work great, but I would have to pull the frig to access the top of the frig. The problem is that the metal skin on the frig is so thin that there is nothing for the sheet metal screws to bite. I posted on irv2 Winnebago forum and someone suggested using a marine adhesive/sealant in combination with the screws for positioning. It is 3M or similar name brand. It worked great. Sorry I can't give you the brand. It is in the freezer at home.