looks to me the failure was casued by excessive torque where the hitch is bolted to the frame. This torque could come from overloading the hitch weight or from a sudden stop while towing with a drop down hitch. Say the toad brakes were not adjusted properly and you have a 5000# toad pushing on even a slightly dropped hitch ball, that can produce a heck of a lot of torque at the hitch mount point and easily exceed the torque max spec determined by weight and distance. Even though everyone thinks they don't overload their hitch, I bet they do occasionally.