LaTriker
I made that exact same tire change from Michelin to Toyo. I paid a total of $2,427.12 two years ago for 6 tires. The cost per tire (w/o mounting, balancing, and tax) was $350.68, which is now ~$375 per tire. I got the tires from our local Les Schwab store, part of a western US tire chain. The owner even came out from behind the counter to shake my hand. They provide great service.
I like the feel of the Toyo tires, and the manager said that they can be re-capped twice. That's probably not an issue with me, because I will probably replace the tires for age rather than tread wear.