Forum Discussion

wca01's avatar
wca01
Explorer
Jan 09, 2015

Fried Oysters

WCA Pan Fried Oysters

I created this recipe when I made a mistake with another recipe.

I love both oyster stew and pan fried oysters. I had them often in my youth, but my wives (I’m on number three) didn’t and don’t care very much about oysters. That means that I have most often had to get fried oysters in restaurants. They seem to always cook them in deep fat fryers.

I don’t like my oysters cooked too much, and it is possible to keep from over cooking them in a deep a fat fryer, but even so, something has been missing from all of the restaurant, deep fat fryer, cooked oysters I have tried. I’m not a chef and have not been able to determine just what has been missing. But a mistake in a recipe obtained from the web showed the truth. Deep fat frying loses all the juices in the oyster, and that is where the greatest flavor is. I don’t mean the oyster liquor; I mean the juice in the oyster itself.

This recipe uses an egg wash to create a little wall around each the oyster to make it a little island and save all of the internal delightful oyster juices.

Ingredients
1 pint fresh select oysters
2 eggs
½ cup all-purpose flour
½ cup self-rising yellow corn meal
1 or 2 tablespoons Peanut oil for cooking

Directions
Drain oysters in a large strainer or colander.

Preheat heavy sauce pan with peanut oil to very high – 350 to 400 F.

Beat eggs in suitable bowl

Mix flour and corn meal in a zip lock bag

Put oysters in zip lock bag with the flour/corn meal mixture
Shake to coat oysters with flour and corn meal

Remove oysters from zip lock bag, reserving the dry mixture in the bag.

Put oysters in egg wash one by one and make sure all oysters are coated with egg wash

Return oysters to zip lock bag and shake to coat all oysters

Add each oyster to hot pan.

Cook until nice and brown, about two minutes, and then flip to cook other side.

Don’t overcook. You want to just get the crust brown without overcooking the oysters. That’s why you need high heated cooking oil.

Don’t over crowd the cooking pan.

After oysters are light brown, place on paper towels to absorb unneeded cooking oil.

Serve with any condiments you desire, but the oysters will speak for themselves.

NOTE.
This recipe uses self-rising cornmeal. That normally is all that is available in the south. That cornmeal contains both baking powder and salt. That’s why there is no salt in this recipe. That works very well for this recipe, but if you can only get non-self-rising corn meal, you will need to add a little salt and baking powder. I don’t know how much, but I’m sure not very much.

The baking powder in the self-rising corn meal, or added to non-self-rising corn meal is what makes the oyster a little island in the flour/corn meal mixture, and that is what keeps all the oyster juices in.

20 Replies

  • Wrap in bacon.......lay them out n sheet pan
    Slip under broiler for couple minutes


    'Angels with wings'......yummmmmmmmmm
  • I like small oysters fried in tempura batter for a light, crisp texture.
  • Pangaea Ron wrote:
    I'm not sure where to begin here. I love oysters, in fact I raise them on my beach. . . I have planted 5,000 Pacific oysters in the last 3 years, along with 12,000 Manila clams, 15,000 Mediterranean mussels, and 36 geoducks.

    They deserve much care. and respect I remove several dozen from my grow bags, scrub them and let them soak in salt water for a bit. I fire up the BBQ and place the oysters cupped side down until they just barely open, when I move them to the side and pry the top shell off, saving as much juice as possible. I then add a bit of sauce that includes melted butter, grated garlic, Tabasco sauce, soy sauce, and lemon juice. I return them to the grill and try to fend off our guests until they are up to temperature again. There is a bit of controversy where some chefs suggest that the top shells should be removed before they are placed on the BBQ. The say that it is easier to control doneness and preserve more juice with this method, but it is more difficult.

    I get my oyster spat from Taylor Shellfish, near me, that is the largest supplier of shellfish in the US. In talking with them I asked if they eat raw oysters, They said NO, and are nervous about how oysters are stored and prepared after they leave their facility. My sister is a microbiologist at a major hospital in Seattle, and says: Don't eat raw oysters, you can't imagine what we see here. Our county regularly tests the bay for contamination, parasites, and pollution, so I feel comfortable with my harvest.

    The only problem this time of year is that all of the low tides are in the middle of the night, and I can't easily access my bounty.


    We call this a hover round. Just hover around with a beer in one hand and a fork in the other. My favorite way to eat oysters.
  • WCA

    Nice preparation. We usually poach them a bit before frying. They seem to hold together for a better presentation for battering and frying.

    I also do that before brining and smoking them. Pure candy when done.

    Did I say that I love oysters.
  • I'm not sure where to begin here. I love oysters, in fact I raise them on my beach. . . I have planted 5,000 Pacific oysters in the last 3 years, along with 12,000 Manila clams, 15,000 Mediterranean mussels, and 36 geoducks.

    They deserve much care. and respect I remove several dozen from my grow bags, scrub them and let them soak in salt water for a bit. I fire up the BBQ and place the oysters cupped side down until they just barely open, when I move them to the side and pry the top shell off, saving as much juice as possible. I then add a bit of sauce that includes melted butter, grated garlic, Tabasco sauce, soy sauce, and lemon juice. I return them to the grill and try to fend off our guests until they are up to temperature again. There is a bit of controversy where some chefs suggest that the top shells should be removed before they are placed on the BBQ. The say that it is easier to control doneness and preserve more juice with this method, but it is more difficult.

    I get my oyster spat from Taylor Shellfish, near me, that is the largest supplier of shellfish in the US. In talking with them I asked if they eat raw oysters, They said NO, and are nervous about how oysters are stored and prepared after they leave their facility. My sister is a microbiologist at a major hospital in Seattle, and says: Don't eat raw oysters, you can't imagine what we see here. Our county regularly tests the bay for contamination, parasites, and pollution, so I feel comfortable with my harvest.

    The only problem this time of year is that all of the low tides are in the middle of the night, and I can't easily access my bounty.
  • Did somebody say oysters??? Bring 'em on.:B You are right, do NOT overcook them. Just enough so they are warm and tender right through. DW does them in egg wash and Panko crumbs.
  • I don't like oysters overcooked either, that's why I eat them raw or pan fried, or deep fried just right. They are tasty in stuffing or stew also. Enjoy :C
  • curses! you've made me sooooo hungry for some good fried oysters! grrrr. :)