Forum Discussion

TomG2's avatar
TomG2
Explorer
Mar 11, 2014

Mexican vanilla-Rooster or not?

This may be one of those "Which way to hang the toilet paper?" questions, but does anyone know which Mexican vanilla is really the best? Some say the stuff with the rooster on the bottle, while others say the opposite. Some say that only glass bottles are good while others say that the plastic is fine. Any Vanilla experts on here?
  • I am with pawatt. Have been buying it for 8 years no problems. We usually get it in the plastic.
  • We like the dark Vanilla with the rooster on the bottle. Have used it for 10 years with total satisfaction.
  • In any case IMHO the Mexican vanaillas (observe the spelling) are superior to those from the US in concentration and volume for the price. We prefer glass containers. Unfortunately we don't go south of the border any more, pity.
  • We once bought a bottle of the White Vanilla ,it had the Rooster on it!
    We gave it as a gift.. The recipient reported that it contained Feathers !

    I will never buy another bottle of Vanilla Extract from a Mexican Store again!

    Incidentally All bottled Vanilla is Vanilla Extract there is no such thing as Pure Vanilla in Liquid form!

    Pure Vanilla comes as a bean!
  • Have not tried them all, so I am no expert. But as long as it is pure vanilla it is about the best your going to get.