Forum Discussion
Lantley
Jan 22, 2017Nomad
westernrvparkowner wrote:Deb and Ed M wrote:Herders do not protect the livestock, they do exactly what the name says, they herd them. They may very well try and corral a bunch of wayward kids, and even might nip at their heels, but they don't attack them. Funny how within this thread we can accept the fact that the bred in instincts and traits are expected and perfectly acceptable when those traits and instincts aren't dangerous. But when a dog that is clearly bred as an attack or protection animal acts instinctively, it is somehow only because the owner is negligent, not because the breed itself has dangerous instincts.BCSnob wrote:ONG wrote:running and screaming children can trigger a reaction in a border collie to try to control the movement with biting used as a means to accomplish control.
In the news today
Children killed by pit bull mix and a border collie. I have never seen a border collie that was mean.
I can also picture how many herding dogs (or heck, dogs in general?), when seeing adults running towards a crying/scared child - might feel compelled to defend the child against the "attackers"? Which might explain why the onlookers said the dogs "just kept coming back"?
I think it also points out Border Collies are not on the list. Should they be?
Can we actually tell what dogs are dangerous and which ones are not?
If these Border collies caused a death should they now be on the list? My dog is on the list, However he is not dangerous. He's been camping for 10 years now without issue.
Begs the question how accurate is the list. Are the CG without breed restrictions constantly having issues with restricted breeds?
About Pet Owners
2,081 PostsLatest Activity: Dec 29, 2024