Forum Discussion

waynefi's avatar
waynefi
Explorer
Sep 22, 2017

Garmin and bad roads

Garmin doesn't seem to know the difference between a good dirt road and a two-track.

On a recent trip to western Colorado and Wyoming, my Garmin Nuvi frequently directed me down bad roads. It tried to sent me past signs "not recommended for passenger cars", "impassable when wet" and "end of county winter maintenance". It tried to send me down two-tracks, private gated roads across someone's ranch, and one turn where I could kinda see that there used to be a two-track once.

This is a car model not an RV model. I am set to shortest time, with highways alowed.

If I turn on "avoid dirt roads", that solves the problem, but does too much. I'm quite happy to drive a good dirt road, but I don't want to do a 4wd track unless I know where it goes.

I would expect Garmin to have a way of marking some roads as "don't choose this unless there is no other way", but apparently they don't.
  • I live on a dead end country road that sits on my property. Google maps shows my road connecting with another road that is 2 miles away. I have a sign posted before entering that says dead end and no trespassing. And people wonder why I get mad when they have to turn their big rigs around in my driveway. Technology is great sometimes but does it trump a posted sign?
    Dave
  • Heheh, Yah, Ms Garmin, my Arch Nemisis....

    It just recently sent me into a private property, dirt roadd... I had the Avoid Dirt option on.

    It'll hang you up.. but so with the others in different areas so just plan on it not being 100% all the time...

    It typically, for me, will take me down the "Yellow Brick Road" out in the Boonies and then "Dump me" saying something like "I don't have the data for this.."...

    I use a back up map when I can't get Google maps up on the tablet. Google has saved my bacon more than a few times where Ms Garmin just didn't know what I was talking about..

    so, not surprising... but plan ahead.

    One trip I learned from another post is use Google earth and ++++ on the roads in doubt. If you see the middle white line, it's paved.. if not? probably dirt...

    Not much help, but you're not alone...

    Good luck..
  • Yeah I've run into this too, even with an RV model. My favorite is when a Township lists a power line right of way as an actual road.

    Can't 100% blame Garmin, they buy their info from third parties who were too lazy to verify the data they are selling.
  • Don't trust it to avoid dirt roads when you turn on "Avoid Dirt Roads", at least in West Virginia. I have an interesting story as to why!

About RV Must Haves

Have a product you cannot live without? Share it with the community!8,793 PostsLatest Activity: Aug 22, 2023