Winegard FlatWave Amplified Razor Thin HDTV Indoor Antenna

Some say good things. Some, not so much. However, as long as it is used the way it was designed to be used (not TOO far from the TV towers) it works very well. The standard antenna is good for 20-25 miles and the amplified antenna is good for 25-35 miles. The Batwing will get you 50-60 miles.

On the first trip I ran a scan and had 11 channels. This was as many as the roof antenna picked up. Seems like a great deal to me so far.

I know of two antennas that are truly omni's but they are also short range.

RV parks tend not to be in the middle of a mess of TV transmission towers (Though there usually one nearby in much of the country) Think long enough and you will figure it out.

I would not bother with this flat job.. I have used flat antennas and they do work if you are in teh "A" band for the station, but ... Been a long time since I was in an "A" band with this RV. less I was in motion at the time.

The packaging claimed no need to turn or position this antenna - works in all directions. I have yet to find any antenna that claims this, to actually be able to do that. When I tried it, I knew that it was not going to work, but decided it was worth a try given whose name was on it.

Winegard specs claim this antenna is multi-directional, which means more than one direction. This antenna would have two directions, front and back.

docj wrote:

1775 wrote:
and despite the claim that it is omni-directional, some of the channels I did get only were there when the antenna was turned in another direction -and then it lost other channels that it had before.

I'm not sure who claimed this antenna was omni-directional, but I seriously doubt it was the manufacturer, Winegard. This kind of antenna is inherently NOT omni-directional and this would be obvious to anyone who understands anything about radio wave propagation and reception.

Most people camp more than 25 miles from a television transmitter tower. I would never consider an antenna like this.

1775 wrote:
and despite the claim that it is omni-directional, some of the channels I did get only were there when the antenna was turned in another direction -and then it lost other channels that it had before.

I'm not sure who claimed this antenna was omni-directional, but I seriously doubt it was the manufacturer, Winegard. This kind of antenna is inherently NOT omni-directional and this would be obvious to anyone who understands anything about radio wave propagation and reception.

I hope that you have better luck with this exact Winegard than I had. I bought it at Costco and it went back the next day. It does get some channels but there are many local channels that it did not get - and despite the claim that it is omni-directional, some of the channels I did get only were there when the antenna was turned in another direction -and then it lost other channels that it had before.

I thought I would try it for the second TV just to see how it works out. Before I started splitting the roof antenna.

I never had a whole lot of luck with those small foot antennas inside my trailer. We usually find ourselves out in the woods somewhere camping off the power grid.

I use the OTA BATWING and it picks up 6-36 digital stations just about anywhere we go here on the East side of the US from the local towns. Up on SKYLINE DRIVE at Loft MTN camp site we go to alot I pickup over 80 channels for different directions looking towards the VA side of the mtn. These are many duplications of channels but gives you many directions to pick the best signals from the various towns that are transmitting the NATL BROADCAST digital signals.

I did a test with using the BATWING verses the JACK antenna and the JACK antenna seemed to give me the strongest signal but was more directional. I would have to move the antenna sometimes to pick up all the local town transmitted signals that were obviously located in different parts of the local town. The BATWING is more wide beam I guess and maybe not as good signal strength wise but I still got great HDTV reception and not have to keep moving the antenna to pick up different stations form the same local town direction.

Works good for me picking up full screen full high def HDTV signals over the 'FREE' to the public NATL BROADCAST network...

Roy Ken