Carlisle or Maxxis

Yes, I have read where Carlisle has re-engineered their tires and are much better today. I just can't seem to find any/many current reviews on them. I have also read where Maxxis is having some problems of late but I can't seem to verify that either. Seems like there should be some kind of failure rate info out there somewhere. Must be top secret stuff the makers don't want out there in the public.

Any recommendations please provide some reasons as to why.