No info on the brands you mentioned, but another ST tire that is getting some good feed back are the newer designed Carlisle RH and HD tires. We have purchased a couple of them in instead of going with Maxxis again and they are holding up well. We have had several sets of Maxxis tires in the past and they are good tires no doubt when it comes to being an ST tire, but they do suffer from the same issues that ST tires deal with when overloaded and under-inflated. We put a lot of miles on them yearly and they are good for about 4 years before they start to show signs of wear and some cracking on sidewalls. Saved some money off the Maxxis price and thus far doing their job well.