Forum Discussion

DaHose's avatar
DaHose
Explorer
Jul 06, 2014

Fixing a REALLY old American Apliance (Suburban) water heater

I have a 1983 Jamboree with the original water heater. The old girl really wasn't used a lot, so the inside of the water heater tank still looks good. However, the electrical bits have failed. The HUGE challenge is that the water heater is an American Appliance brand. They were bought out about 20 years ago by Suburban, but at 30 years old it is seemingly impossible to find listings of correct parts or ANY original spares. A new, direct spark heater is upwards of $400, so I decided to try and bring the water heater back to life.

At first, the heater would click the direct spark ignition, but I would get no flame. Through trial and error I realized that the lower solenoid on the gas valve was dead. The big issue is that the valve/regulator is different than what the Suburban brand uses. Unable to find replacement solenoids ANYWHERE, I tinkered and realized that the solenoid bodies just unscrew from the valve. By removing the lower solenoid and taking out the spring and pin, I was able to bypass it and run on just the top one. That is when I realized that the heater would start up when I clicked the switch and then go out 15 or so seconds later. Those symptoms indicated a faulty flame sensor or controller board. The flame sensor looked OK, but at $20, it seemed worth the risk of trying first. Replacing the flame sensor didn't help, so I searched for a DinosaurElectronics controller board. Lo and behold, the controller for the Suburban water heaters is exactly the same as on my 30 year old antique. The heater now seemed to be working with a UIB-L installed. Total spent was $120.





Move forward 5 months. Believing the heater was working, I installed a hybrid heat upgrade so that we could operate on electric or propane. Niiiiiiiiiiiice.:C Since that has been installed, I have been working on other "stuff" the past couple of weeks and tested the gas supply only to realize that the upper gas solenoid of the water heater is now dead. Time for a tough choice. Do I NOW say "screw this" and buy a new water heater, or do I try to save my investment? That question led to some creative thinking and I purchased the gas valve/solenoid shown below. My thought was to try disabling both solenoids (stuck permanently open) on the existing regulator/valve and inserting two of these replacement solenoids upstream in the gas line. That would allow the controller to open/close the gas feed as necessary, but being far away from the valve itself could create a lag in getting gas to the burner. I was worried that too much time between solenoid opening and ignition would cause other problems, but at $20 it was worth one last shot.



When I had things apart I realized there might be a better alternative. I removed the acorn nut on top of the new solenoids and the coil pack just slid off. Also, the hole in the coil pack is big enough to go around the stripped bodies of my existing solenoids. I could only fit around one existing solenoid body, but I put the the guts back inside the lower solenoid body, put the new coil pack on, applied 12V ..... and ...... IT CLICKED!!!!



In the pic. above, the upper solenoid has been gutted so it is essentially "stuck" open. The lower solenoid is now TOTALLY FUNCTIONAL with the new coil pack. When I switch on the heater, the ignition sparks, the flame catches and the water heater works just like when it was new. A new direct spark water heater with electric option is upwards of $600 and I just repaired/converted mine for less than $200. WOOHOO! I plan to add a second solenoid in the gas line and wire it together with the one at the regulator/valve. The double solenoids are about safety and I am down with that! I am now very confident the hot water tank will last through the lifetime that we own it.

I am very happy with the results.:)

Jose

7 Replies

  • Way to go!
    It's always nice to see someone thinking out side the box.
    It now looks like you have all the safety of the original install.
    Those that don't understand will always find a way to condemn.

    Richard
  • Took the old girl out this weekend and exercised the water heater. Both the repaired propane system electrics and the 110v upgrade operated exactly as expected.

    Jose
  • I still need to find a new burner tube, but I got the second solenoid installed. Here you can see I just threaded on some fittings to the valve and inserted it inline, where the gas line connects to the actual water heater.



    An unforeseen plus is that I can hear it click open from inside the RV when the water heater cycles on. Audible cues are nice.

    Jose
  • I've looked all over for parts in local shops, online and spoken with the couple repair centers in my local area to no avail. Another option was to convert to the current valve and burner assembly from a Suburban water heater, but at that point I would replace the heater altogether.

    I fully understand the safety function of the dual solenoids and I will end up with two solenoids on the system. One solenoid will be the original that I have repaired with the solenoid coil of the new valve. The insides still look brand new and it is functioning perfectly. I actually ordered two of the new gas valves and I will install the complete valve a little further up-stream in the main gas line. That will duplicate the function of the upper solenoid that cuts off the primary feed.

    The burner tube is solid, but covered in surface rust. That part I can still find as it is the same as on the current Suburban heaters. I was going to wait to order it, but you make a good point Joseph. Why not just change it now, before it rots out completely? I need to get one ordered.

    I already added a Camco Hybrid Heat kit. You can see it in the bottom of the pic. It's the red wires coming out of where the drain valve used to be. I also added a new anode rod.

    I do realize you must be very careful when dealing with propane appliances and am taking proper care to leak test all connections.

    Jose
  • past-MIdirector wrote:
    From a 25 year Appliance tech. either convert to all electric with a Hot Rod kit or replace the water heater. Bypassing/eliminating a gas solenoid is a fire or possible explosion waiting to happen since the two solenoids are a safety design!!!! Water heaters start a about $450. Your burner tube is just about rust out and bypassing the gas valve is an accident waiting to happen.

    X2, you're playing with fire!

    Maybe an RV wrecking yard would have some parts for you.
  • From a 25 year Appliance tech. either convert to all electric with a Hot Rod kit or replace the water heater. Bypassing/eliminating a gas solenoid is a fire or possible explosion waiting to happen since the two solenoids are a safety design!!!! Water heaters start a about $450. Your burner tube is just about rust out and bypassing the gas valve is an accident waiting to happen.

About Technical Issues

Having RV issues? Connect with others who have been in your shoes.24,260 PostsLatest Activity: Jun 05, 2025