Having problem with new batteries going dead Fast!

Let's not get distracted, hopefully the OP still reads this. Fridge was in LP mode - or so he says.

Need to know volts. What does it mean "battery dead", - there is no such reading on this controller :).

I would not trust 95% evening charge or 10% morning charge on the controller either - not clear what this is based on.
Morning voltage before solar kicks in is more informative. Tell us the volts, please.