Forum Discussion
homefor2
Jan 17, 2015Explorer
j-d wrote:
Is it a "One-Time" ECO? Some are. Let me offer a few guesses, NOT based on experience:
Yes once it's burned out it's like a fuseā¦.done.
1. Is the Water Heater actually FULL? Say you'd drained it. Turn water on then power on, possibly you were heating some air and the tank of the heater without adequate water to dissipate the element's heat.
Definitely full. Been using it for a month with propane.
2. Thermostat Stuck, to the point the system got hot enough to trip the ECO.
The thermostat is part of the part I replaced so I think it's unlikely the new one would also fail.
3. Element damaged with either a hot spot or a short.
Tested the element with a meter for the correct resistance and it looks good. I would have to buy another ECO to experiment AGAIN if I don't figure this out.
An Element is probably cheaper than an ECO. Don't just get one at the Big Box that physically matches yours. Match the WATTAGE also. RV's can't provide the current most home water heaters use.
How do you Drain this WH? Anode Rod means Suburban and Plastic Plug means Atwood...
Definitely a Suburban. Drained by removing the anode.
Thanks for trying.
About Technical Issues
Having RV issues? Connect with others who have been in your shoes.24,369 PostsLatest Activity: Mar 11, 2026