Water Hearter Source For Full-Time
I live full-time in my 5th wheel. With that in mind, do you guys use propane or electric to heat your water. Suggestions and why please. Thanks guys, David
Forum Discussion
ENG2242 wrote:
Problematic....
Well, as I stated/implied. are there any potential mechanical issues that may develop as a result of using either/or after a prolonged period of time. This is my 10th RV, so I am familiar with them. I've just never lived in one full time. I have a 250lb propane tank, so that's not the issue. Once again, is either/or going to cause parts failure over the other after pro longed use. I'm now being redundant in an attempt to clarify a fundamental question.
Regards,
David
Only problematic when one quits working.
Then you fix it and continue using it.
Electric is slowest recovery time --- roughly 6 gal/hr from initial fill (70*F water temp)
Propane is quicker --- roughly 10 gal/hr (70*F water temp)
BOTH at same time --- 16 gal/hr
Electric vs propane
If an Atwood brand then electric element can be difficult to access. It is installed from backside of WH Tank
If Suburban brand then elctric element is easier to access as it is in outside compartment under the burner tube
Both have all propane components in outside compartment and are easy to repair
Electric element issues are usually 'operator error' ---turning it on w/o water in tank
Propane issues are usuaully due to mud dabbers or spider webs interfering with propane flow (system is only 0.4psi)
Propane spark electrode getting sooty/carboned up WILL cause ignition failures
General routine 'housekeeping' goes a long way in preventing issues.
