Replacement lid from Fan-Tastic Vent showed up.

They also sent a new lift arm assembly, not sure why but I went ahead and swapped it out.

New lid is smoke, wasn't sure what color I was getting. Its nice, can see thru it, and lets light thru, camera doesn't like it.

Ended up with 12" between the 2 14" holes. Forgot how much fun the Dicor self leveling caulk is. While I had the 2 holes open I should have prerun wire across the roof for when/if planned solar panel addition happens, hindsight.
More than likely I'm pulling off the shroud today, painting the AC base white and some of the metal bits exposed behind grill -it really stands out. Maybe it wont look as tall as it is but the black bugs me. Replace the shroud screws with stainless, slow the rust down a bit. Piddly stuff.
Edit:

New vent lid. Removed the shroud and paint most of the sheet metal bits and screws with zinc, painted what showed thru grill black (not condenser). Painted the base white.
I also sealed the hole that leads inside where wires pass. The hole is in one top of the plastic fan housing, looks like half a tube of sealant was squirted in but still didn't seal top of hole. From inside (with shroud off) I could see light. ? Where its at probably only would have leaked while driving in hard rain.

White base just looks better to me, less visible to my eye anyway. Now were done.