Forum Discussion

AnEv942's avatar
AnEv942
Nomad
May 26, 2014

Bargman LED conversion

For your entertainment...Though stoked with our new LEDs, and just posting pics (ok showing off) of our conversion nothing new here or ground breaking. However relating the rewiring of grounds I found might be worth re posting- passing along. That and yet another source of possible water leak.

As I needed to remove our Bargman 84 series taillights to clean and reseal (again) I revisited replacing with LEDs. I do this periodically, looking at the LED conversion, but always balk at the cost- no real justification. However I stumbled upon a fella selling one for half price, looking around found another....so without taking the time to reflect on the practicality I ordered. As neither kit was suppose to be delivered until after we return from short trip, decided to go ahead-pull and clean up reseal the fixtures.

Though the LED conversion is simply plug in new light in place of bulb, screw down lens I have 2 issues to address. One is my housings are warping, top corners pulling away from camper wall. Second is a lot of corrosion and more than I realized once I removed lens.



Pictures dont show amount of corrosion on the left taillight which I took pics of while doing but Im suprised they still worked. Even worse though was the right taillight.



The lights ground path relies on the mechanical swagged socket connection to the backing/reflector plate. To the back side of plate the ground lead is riveted along with a small jumper bar that is riveted to the back up light. Any of these connection points, whether thru corrosion or becoming loose will cause lose of ground.

Between the corrosion and warped housings-started thinking maybe I should have just ordered new taillights. Got on line to see what housings, if available, might cost as I had Conversion kits in transit.
I came across several posts where folks simply by pass the mechanical ground path and solder ground leads directly to the sockets. Welp-thats worth a try...



After some serious cleaning of old putty tape and caulk from both the light and camper, took housing to the shop. Ive soldered on old lights before-usually without a lot of success. Surprisingly once I cleaned and filed a small spot, solder stuck to sockets like they were pre-tinned. Odd-but not complaining. I assumed to do this I would end up spot welding ground tabs on sockets though require removing wires and spring.



Soldered new ground wire leads to the sockets and passed thru the backing plate. New grounds are in conjunction with or alternate to, depending, with existing ground path.



Wire nutted leads back together. Because the lights don't have an actual mounting surface, its literally an edge with V shape hollow, I rolled putty tape to fill the v shaped groove so hopefully will give more adhesion area to the final ribbon of tape. Im surprised more folks don't see these leaking. On to the right taillight.



As mentioned on this fixture the internal corrosion was even worse. My opinion is housing is mounted upside down. The internal surface of box mounted horizontally, one side is sloped. I think it should be on bottom. Any water getting past the unsealed lens (constant) will just drain out. This one the slope surface was on top, obvious water has puddled on the flat bottom behind lens. Also with sloped edge at top any water leaking past perimeter seal was naturally directed into camper wall. Though just surface and no signs of rot obviously wall getting wet.

Drilled out all the rivets, pulled the backing plates with sockets and swapped so I can reinstall with the slope on bottom. Once connecting ground bar removed, release two 'clips' at one edge then slide plate down out of slot. Ive never noted a left/right fixture so not sure how this is supposed to work? Unfortunately we haven't had any real rain so camper was dry.
Cleaned up housing, added new ground leads, reinstalled on camper.



All clean, sealed and shiny with positive ground path. The added corners screws will get sealed once putty sets.



And then the new LED lights magically appeared... 2 days instead of scheduled 7-10 days? Setting on the bench, tracking still showed project delivery next week...The one was mailed 2 day priority from IN-the other std first class from NC, were in CA.



Wow put your eyes out kid.
Without much more thought, though puzzling, sat up to test & verify. Thats 0.1 amps on brake. Standard 1157 bulb showed 2.4 amps...



Niiice at least I like em. Not so sure I would want to be behind them. I installed only the left led 1st to compare led/incandescent. Night and day. Had the truck backed up off to side to plug into bumper. I could see both truck and camper tail lights. The difference, especially when turn signal on is amazing.
Appearance wise makes the led backup worth considering...almost



We have sealed beams for actually being able to see so these only act as eye level backup 'indicators'. I'll probably try to find some led bulbs or maybe let-in some led fixtures into lens. Removing the unnecessary 4-5 amp load, (more available for sealed beams), and allow keeping lens for the reflectors. TBD
  • I have those same taillights on my camper as well, I concur on the brightness. I also put LED backup lights in, and those I'm good with being super bright.

    I went one step further though, I replaced all of the clearance lights around the top of the camper with the Bargman LED replacements. The red ones are like five brake lights at the top of the camper, those can be seen for miles around. In a dark camping spot they throw a red glow over everything.

    -Joe
  • One thing about LEDs: when they turn on (like a blinking turn signal does) the slope from nothing to full brightness is very steep, much steeper than an incandescent bulb. The human eye isn't used to this, most light sources in nature are pretty slowly varying. So when hit by the very fast time constant LED slope, you eye can perceive that unnaturally fast slope as a flash, settling to a lower brightness level than the initial impression. You see this in LED street signals as well. It's probably good for stop lamps and turn signals because it attracts attention, even in the peripheral vision.

    There have been some studies done on the perception of brightness between incandescent and LED lights for aircraft. Even at the same luminosity measured by objective instruments, colored LEDs were perceived brighter, due apparently to being more saturated color.
  • Thanks for the helpful post.

    I'm planning on doing same thing.
  • Some of the newer cars are hurt your eyes bright. Ive converted all of our trailers, jeep etc to leds, they are bright and crisp but not annoyingly so. Most of the tractor/trailer rigs again bright but tolerable. These Bargman conversions are as bright as most led equipped EM vehicles. Tail isnt bad but the brake/signal is. I think due to nothing else on that circuit, camper only. I did note on the road other campers with the Bargman LEDs, probably factory-They werent piercingly as bright as mine. Could just be the output from truck.
    They are DOT approved which I believe covers output-not sure. Then again LEDs just emit differently. I want to be seen and stoked with the new lights but dont need to be a tom about it. No one flipped me off but did allow me to change lanes when wanted. Maybe so I would turn blinker off...
  • I follow a lot of vehicles that have LED tail lights and wonder why they are all driving with their foot on the brake pedal. Standard driving light levels are too bright. I'm surprised DOT doesn't establish a standard output requirement.
  • Wasnt planned but having returned from a week out with new LED taillights decided to update this with a usage report. Not in the functionality of the new LEDs but in the response from other drivers. Simply Amazing.

    After the first day on highway became obvious the greater visibility of the LEDs had an impact in how others responded to the taillights. Normally if I need to change lanes, turning, slowing down etc folks responded at their convenience, or usually I turn on blinker and wait for that one more car that needs to get by me first. This trip I turn on the blinker or brake folks actually back peddled. When I hit the brakes werent running up my bumper.

    I was a bit self conscious when setting at a stop light how bright they are for the guy behind me but had no idea other drivers would actually react to them like they did. Swear I heard 'Holy chit! that guys turning, now'.

    Not sure why folks react to them differently than the incandescents, brighter yes, but seemed more like I was making an undeniable statement of intent that forced immediate response verses a request or plea that can be ignored if inconvenient ... kinda funny but just unexpected.

    Due to HOW bright I was planning to add voltage regulators to camper brake/turn circuits to ensure the 2 single LEDs not overdriven, mostly for longevity. I think they are receiving too much voltage, trailer in tow will help...rethinking as it would dim just a tad :).
  • After tightening the wire nut
    fill it with silicone.
    Lasts 5-10 years in a marine environment.
    Actually can't remember any ever failing.
  • I breifly thought about painting but too late. Though I think just by design too flimsy with too few screws. Yes as mentioned the housing IMO have top & bottom mounted horz but I assume they are all assembled the same? And one of em is going to be upside down when orienting function? 'course less an issue if sealed...

    One was from private party-which is what motivated me, the second- best price I could find was 31.5 shipped thru ebay Bargman 47-84-410.
    Just FYI if looking the 47-84-410 and 42-84-410 are the same (red)led replacement lens. The 42- & 47- refers to packaging. The 42- is hard plastic pkg, the 47- is in a plastic bag. Hence youll see different dimension for product.

    While I tend to agree on wire nuts used in automotive use not the best choice by far, especially where wire can move/exposed, these once installed are tucked inside wall fairly snug so no movement. Orientated nuts vertically so no moisture can collect, they replaced crimped on wire nuts. As I may try to come up with something on the B/Us so other than resealing base, ease of removing. Otherwise I generally reach for the soldering iron but RV lights I don't consider permanent. Hmm I did deform the crimp on nuts to inspect wire for corrosion-none, wonder if its the brass bulb in steel socket mounted to aluminum plate mixed with water. ha
  • Weak point in the future is wire nuts. They're not at all weather resistant and good place for corrosion if they don't loosen first.
    BTW where did you find the LED replacements?
  • I think the black plastic frame/trim distort in sunlight more so than the white plastic frames.

    Thank you for sharing your very good/smart mod on the water drainage.