Forum Discussion

Mike_Up's avatar
Mike_Up
Explorer
Jan 24, 2016

Considering another Pop Up BUT

I was considering another pop up but my wife demands some features. 1st a toilet, 2nd a TV for rain days and late night, 3rd a Freezer for pizzas and other things, and 4th above knee kitchen item storage.

Jayco is completely out. In fact there's no storage on their 1208SC at all. No silverware, towel, or pot/pan storage. Then there's no food storage or even a place to put a 28 bottle case of water.

We don't want a Highwall as cost is overpriced.

I've yet to find a freezer in a Pop Up other than a Highwall, and little cabinet room to bring a stand alone compressor portable freezer. The only pop ups that offer overhead storage are Forest River in their Rockwood campers, and don't have any competent dealer service shops to even deal with preventive maintenance or even warranty repairs.

There's no Coachmen/Viking or Palomino dealers within a 2.5 hour drive. And there's no Jayco or Starcraft pop up Floorplans I'd even consider. I actually hate the Jayco pop ups the worst. They have no storage at all, have interior lift system, table heights and benchs are much lower than any other competitor and feel child like, and uncomfortable.

So the only dealers that even sell pop ups near us that I like are Forest River and they don't have any service techs to repair anything and the other being Jayco, that I won't consider. I also had horrible experiences with Forest River Rockwood pop ups, service, and customer service that makes me uncomfortable even considering them.

I was happy to see that the Hot water heaters in most have been upgraded to DSI but the thetford cassette toilet still are not tied into the water system's holding tank and pump.

They must have water poured in to the toilets own small fresh water tank, through a funnel from a portable gallon tank. Then you must empty that fresh water from the toilet before traveling or as thetford says, damage may happen. Why haven't they put in a more up to date toilet system yet?

Either I keep my travel trailer or go back to tenting if the need arises.

The Forest River I was considering was the 2716G Premier but was put off when I saw the toilet fill wasn't tied into the water system!

The 2716G has enough cabinet top space and storage that we need and a stop to put a TV that can be viewed from the seated positions but I don't want to deal with a porti potty when I paying for a toilet. At price of $8k when I was by myself, that was OK, but not at prices of $13K when I have a family that will use it often.

Are there any pop ups that have a toilet tied into the water system other than highwalls?

28 Replies

  • In that case, I'll point out that I know of many owners of small, molded-fiberglass TTs who tow them with V6 SUVs. A 3500/350 tow capacity is sufficient for most of those, like 16' Scamp or Casita (but the 17' Casita tends to be too hitch-heavy, over 350 lbs). Besides being easy to maneuver and easier to see around (narrower bodies than most TTs), they have lower wind resistance and you might get around 15 mpg towing them. That's not far from what I got when towing the popups.

    The one thing on your list that they may lack is a freezer compartment... I'm not certain. Add a small Truckfridge (the 12V compressor allows setting as freezer) somewhere in your rig and you might be set.
  • The cassette toilet was a breeze to operate...manually filling the flush tank was less than a five minute ordeal. Makes it nice that your potable water supply isn't diminished by the flush water. Clean up was much nicer too. That is the dump was much easier and cleaner.

    I didn't see what your plan was for the pizza after you figure out how to freeze it. Most if not all low wall pups are not equipped with a stove.

    We have sold the pup...it was not working for my family...first heavy thunderstorm and my wife was done. I do wish to caution you, really be sure you can make the pup work. CCC is a huge issue with these things, especially if you go for a wet bath, and a slide out.

    I've been considering a 26BH like yours after your positive reviews of it. I don't like slides and the 26bh seems to be the best no slide trailer out there right now.

    Thanks and good luck no matter what you decide.

    Thanks

    Jeremiah
  • rexlion wrote:
    I've had a popup (Starcraft) for 1 season, and an Aliner for 1 season. The counter height and total lack of upper storage were big minuses for me, too.

    If I were you, I'd keep the TT... and maybe buy a $100-$200 tent for those times when you get the urge for the sound of flapping canvas. ;)

    Why were you thinking of selling the TT, anyhow? Just wondering what your motivations are.


    Not real happy with how Ford and GM have raised the price of their trucks so much in the last couple years, so was thinking of a less capable and more affordable tow vehicle. Plus some of the homes we thought about buying don't have a lot of accessible property for a travel trailer. A smaller trailer will fit better.

    Or I'll just keep what I have and run the miles over a 100K and hope for the best in resale value.

    BTW, I already have 2 Eureka tents I use when I can. :) :)
  • I've had a popup (Starcraft) for 1 season, and an Aliner for 1 season. The counter height and total lack of upper storage were big minuses for me, too.

    If I were you, I'd keep the TT... and maybe buy a $100-$200 tent for those times when you get the urge for the sound of flapping canvas. ;)

    Why were you thinking of selling the TT, anyhow? Just wondering what your motivations are.
  • I couldn't afford a new one either. We looked for about 4 months to find one, but we are glad we did. Way more room than a pop up and tows better than a normal TT, plus I can get it in my 84" high garage door opening.

    Mike Up wrote:
    Bowfreak wrote:
    Look for a used Trailmanor. Best of both worlds.


    No used trailmanors by me or even a new dealer. Besides, I could store my trailer or buy a Highwall tent trailer and be money ahead with the price of a new trailmanor.

    Thanks for the idea though.
  • Bowfreak wrote:
    Look for a used Trailmanor. Best of both worlds.


    No used trailmanors by me or even a new dealer. Besides, I could store my trailer or buy a Highwall tent trailer and be money ahead with the price of a new trailmanor.

    Thanks for the idea though.