Forum Discussion

martyn8677's avatar
martyn8677
Explorer
Aug 12, 2014

Door #1 or Door #2

Ready to buy a camper and I'm down to two. Really struggling with this and thought I would ask for some feedback.

Both dealers are giving me the same exact amount for my trade in, so that is a wash. Both campers have the same options on them generally. I would be happy with either as an upgrade over my current camper.

Camper 1 is a 2009 Lance, 60 hours on the generator so lightly used, dealer certified. I prefer this floor plan of the two. I can buy it for $3,000 BELOW NADA Low Retail, but I have to travel 1,100 miles to pick it up.

Camper 2 is an 2012 Adventurer, literally looks brand new inside. 5 hours on the generator. I can buy this camper for $1,300 ABOVE NADA Low Retail, and only travel 300 miles to get it.

My out of pocket cost is $1,200 more for Camper 2 the Adventurer, but travel expense will be much less obviously.

Purely on numbers and like new condition, I would go with Camper 2. But I keep going back to Camper 1 being my preferred floor plan and NADA values Lance $3,000 - $4,000 higher than the Adventurer, though NADA does not take into account how new/unused the Adventurer is versus the Lance. It simply values both as used.

Haha, hope this isn't too confusing.

Thoughts?
  • Did you do a walk around on both of them or just see them through an advertisement?
    I am partial to Lance, because I own one. We purchased it based on the floor plan we were looking for.
  • Pick the Lance ...

    Make a camping trip out of getting it, test it on the way home, and Lance dealers are all over the USA if you need parts or repairs.
  • Cash will be gone quick, floor plans last almost forever...
  • Even if out of pocket expenses were exactly the same, folks generally say pick the floor plan you like the best. Does your wife look the same today as the day you got married? Okay, don't answer that. But my point is that the "new" look will soon deminish and you would have a less desireable floor plan. Get the one that you will love into old age. ;-)
  • Well I'm beginning the same sort of dilemma! They are both nice campers!

    The way I look at it though is that in the LONG run the dollars/NADA prices, etc. you are talking about don't really matter if you get what you want in the first place and plan to keep it for a while. Of course it's not my $$ either and I don't mean that the $$ are not important! This is why I'm waiting for the "perfect" one to come along. If it were me I would go for the Lance if that's the floor plan, etc. you want. I would hate to be saying to myself months/years down the road.. "darn, I wish I had bought the one I really wanted instead of worrying about the NADA retail charts.."

    Best of luck in whatever you do! Don't forget photos! WE LOVE photos! :)

    Dak