jus2shy wrote:
With that kind of thinking, we'd ought to throw away all efforts in heavy freight to increase fuel economy, like the Walmart Super-trucks that break 10 mpg towing at full weight. Averaging 10.7 when I last read
Some want to RV, but they want as much fuel economy as possible for a given tow setup, or their tow vehicle isn't a purely dedicated towing machine. I'm personally glad to see lots of aero being put into the newest 5'er and tow vehicles (hence the huge air dams on the front and optimizing of shapes around the doors and windshield angles). It may only give 1 mpg here or 0.5 mpg there, but it all adds up. If freight operators can worry about fuel economy why not the average RV'er eh?
You are comparing an over the road truck that likely averages 150K miles a year. Saving 1 mpg over 150K miles is worthwhile. its likely saving 2000 + gallons of diesel per year at $4 a gallon. That is $8000 a year savings.
The OP mentioned that he isn't planning to drive often, just full time snow birding. Worrying about saving 30 gallons of gas per year and not having enough truck isn't smart. You might save $100 on fuel but you are either over weight and your truck is struggling and wasting gas, or you had to settle for a smaller trailer and aren't happy.
Or you get the bigger rear axle ratio, spend $100 more a year on fuel and have plenty of truck to enjoy your trip.
You CAN worry about fuel economy, but you probably won't enjoy the experience nearly as much...