jmckelvy wrote:
As an EE I am always interested in electrical problems. From looking at the Atwood links posted earlier it does not appear these jacks are the typical Atwood Truck Camper jacks most of us are familiar with which work as Bigfootford described.
Truck camper jacks do not and should not connect in any way to the "frame" of the camper. How could that work as many truck campers have wooden frames. These appear to be jacks designed for attachment to a trailer and therefore a metal frame is available.
A good wiring diagram would really help solve the problem. It's hard to tell but from one of the posted links it appears that a ground wire connects to the jack and two other wires attach to the motor. This will work with a motor with a fixed ground as long as the two wires attached to the motor go to different windings in the motor...power to one turns one way... power to the other turns the other way.
Good luck troubleshooting the problem. Be sure to post when you find the solution.
Right about the OP's Atwood jack install being different....
He clarified the wiring... 4 wires on the drivers side... and 2 on the passenger side. Switches are on the drivers side. Without a wiring diagram we can only surmise that:
2 wires on the drivers side are + and - from the battery
2 wires go over to the passenger side jack.
Switches probably provide the reversing of polarity to the motor (s) simple as that. No relays needed.
Double pole/double throw...
Although using just switches the current handling of the switches need to be in the 20 amp region for each motor.
I have designed a remote control for Stablelift systems for a friend... I used switches that controlled relays... Much better current handling..
The body of the jack while metal should be impervious to the - /ground of anything if in fact the 2 wires from the battery have one that is - (negative). The motor body should not enter into the operation. Atwood/Happijac etc use simple dc motors with 2 isolated leads for power.
I believe this diagram from atwood is not how the OP's jack switches are implemented. I have not got an answer as of yet.
Look at #11.
http://www.askforatwood.com/manuals/chassis/66199.pdfAll said, if the - wire from the battery has no connection then the jacks should not work and there should be no arching... The path back to the battery should be through the - wire not the Jack bracket... So at this point I/we are all guessing.
Time to get the DVM out and go to work!
Jim