Forum Discussion

RoyBell's avatar
RoyBell
Explorer
Jul 16, 2019

How to value trade?

How do you value trade on a camper?

NADA comes back retail low: $16,550, Average retail:$19,950

Can someone explain what these numbers mean? Are these prices that someone should expect to pay from a dealer? There is currently one camper like mine for sale, listed @ 18K, and several others of similar style by the same company for around the same ($18K).

I may be biased, but mine is in much better condition than those listed. They have blemishes throughout the insides. We pride ourselves on maintaining stuff and keeping it as new condition. Rugs inside, stored inside vs outside, regular maintenance, cleaned after every use, etc.

The reason I bring this up is because a local dealer gave me a price on my trade without even looking at it. They offered $12K, which is on the low end of what I expected from a dealer for trade. However, if they offer $12K to everyone, based on 25% under low retail, I would expect I have some bargaining room then since I feel mine is in better condition.

Are there any formulas based on Nada and what is for sale to see what I should expect for trade value? I know they say approx 25% under Nada, but which number?

I could try to sell private, but it was a headache when I did that with my Pop-up. @ $12,000 trade in price, I would save approx $1000 on tax savings. Selling for $16,000 privately (low retail) would net me an extra $3,000, even with the tax loss, which does seem more appealing...unless the dealer is willing to give more on trade anyways.
  • Well, it's hard to put a value on something when I don't know what it would be worth. I had a number in my head between 12-16K, which is quite a spread.

    KBB gives a better indication on what "trade-in" should be vs "buying from private party or dealer". Just wasn't sure what to expect in a trade-in.

    I am not in a rush to sell as I have a place to store it and don't need the equity, though it would be nice to have it up front. I put it on craigslist for $18K to see if I get any bites. In my experience it's hard to sell vehicles over $12K on CL though.
  • "IF" (that's a Big If) the condition is everything you say it is, the dealer is not going to give you more than $16K. So I would negotiate with the dealer until he came up to the $16K. This will be extremely difficult because dealers negotiate every day for a living and are way better at it then most people. So if you are in a hurry to buy, your in a tight spot; over the proverbial barrel so to speak. If you are in no hurry and can spend the time sell it outright or wait the dealer out. Once again, this all hinges on the Big If.
  • Dealers offer low prices so they can sell it and make a profit. If you want what you think it's worth then you will need to endure the headache and sell it yourself. Dealers know what you will have to deal with and try to make as much profit as possible. That's why they lowball everyone.