Good luck with any of them.
I have Progressive and other than the price, have been pleased with what they offer.
They all play games, and they are all in it together. Went with Progressive for their "agreed value" benefit. Progressive wooed me with lower rates, etc. and did pretty well, initially. Since then, my auto rates have gone up 20 percent a year (2 years now) for no reason at all. No claims, no tickets, safe driver, excellent credit, blah blah. (at least the rise was offset by my TT rate going down)
Their explanation was twofold. One, there are a lot of bad drivers out there and everyone gets lumped into a giant pool so the cost is spread out. Translation: Good drivers are lumped in with all the bad drivers and paying more because of them.
Two, they told me they basically need the money. Yep. They had to pay a lot of claims, so I (and all the other good, responsible customers) get to help. That pool thing again. And there is nothing anyone can do about it, except change companies constantly.
And since insurance is REQUIRED, they can do whatever they want. If it was a choice, bet things would be different.