Forum Discussion

billtex's avatar
billtex
Explorer II
Aug 09, 2018

Michelin vs Falken

Had a tragic failure on my Nitto DT at 4 yrs old last week (ask Buzz how scary that can be!) so I am pulling all of them off and getting new skins.
Thought I made up my mind on Falken Wildpeak H/T purchased from tire buyer (they have been great with Customer service). When I went to my install Guy he said “no way would I run foreign tires” with the loads I carry. He suggested Michelin Defender LTX M/S (purchased from TB as he could not match their price). He runs Michelins on his tow trucks, flat beds, etc. and say he sells more of these to commercial guys than any other brand.
So I call TB back and they say “Michelin are known for the softest sidewall in the market”! (Never heard that before).
So. Now I am confused.
I prefer a highway tread (AT’s too squirmy for me. And I am to off roading anyway). Cost not an issue-want the most robust 285 75 16 LR 126 out there.
For those running this Michelin-what is your experience?

I hate buying new tires!!!

Thx, Bill

45 Replies

  • Been fan of Michelins for over 20 years and cracks are known issue, but IMHO they outpriced the brand from the market.
    That said my new dually truck come on Michelins.
    No complains.
    But I live in Nevada where my house see rain 3-4 times a year, when generally Michelins suck in slippery conditions.
    That said each tire model is different, so check the reviews.
  • billtex wrote:
    Had a tragic failure on my Nitto DT at 4 yrs old last week (ask Buzz how scary that can be!) so I am pulling all of them off and getting new skins.
    Thought I made up my mind on Falken Wildpeak H/T purchased from tire buyer (they have been great with Customer service). When I went to my install Guy he said “no way would I run foreign tires” with the loads I carry. He suggested Michelin Defender LTX M/S (purchased from TB as he could not match their price). He runs Michelins on his tow trucks, flat beds, etc. and say he sells more of these to commercial guys than any other brand.
    So I call TB back and they say “Michelin are known for the softest sidewall in the market”! (Never heard that before).
    So. Now I am confused.
    I prefer a highway tread (AT’s too squirmy for me. And I am to off roading anyway). Cost not an issue-want the most robust 285 75 16 LR 126 out there.
    For those running this Michelin-what is your experience?

    I hate buying new tires!!!

    Thx, Bill


    Glad you made it through the blow out. It is one hell of a white knuckle ride when a tire lets loose with the camper in the bed. I had the TOYO Open Country in the 285/75R16 on my blow out. I still have that SRW truck as a back up to my dually and I am running Cooper 19.5s , no way I would ever feel comfortable running 16s on my truck with a camper ever again
  • I have the Michelin LTX Defender's on my F350 and have no issues with them, nor cracking. Also my brother uses the same on his F350 and no issues either. I do have the FX4 package on my truck which comes with 20" rim's so I don't have as much sidewall to flex compared to 16" rims I suppose.
  • Michelins do flex a lot in the sidewalls. This leads to developing cracks early in life. Mich tech says cracks that you can't get your fingernail into are fine. Hit the Class A forum and search on 'Michelin'. See you if a few days :)

    There seems to be a cult following and no number of cracks will discourage them from buying. I run them on the toad, but I went with Yokos on the Sahara.
  • I had Michelin LTX on my F350 and hated them. Went to Nokian Rotiiva AT Plus tires and have been very happy. Great ride, higher load rating and great traction. I wouldn't have any concern about running foreign tires. Check the load ratings and tread design you want and feel confident on the road.