valhalla360 wrote:
philh wrote:
mix and match, change up if you like. Today's it's an old wives tale, that actually had a basis of fact in the past.
Friend was a mechanic that had a car come in with a failed engine. A little thick sludge came out of the drain. After an investigation, turns out the female owner religiously took her car to the same quickie oil change place for an oil change every 3000 miles... except for (IRC) 50,000 miles, it never got changed.
Sounds like one of those apocryphal stories that never happened. At best, it may have been a lie when she was trying to get a warranty claim after never changing the oil.
They might be able to trick her on the filter but if you are sitting in the car, you can typically see them putting the oil in.
An oil change place that doesn't change the oil would get caught by someone real quick and then get run out of business as not all people are stupid.
He was a dealership mechanic, and I personally knew him. He had photos of the remaining sludge in the pan, and also buildup on the heads.
I did ask the question, how did the car last that long? They speculated the oil was "topped" off every time she came in for an oil change.
Engines are surprisingly resilient to bad owner behavior. My step daughter trashed her engine. She bought a used car and had it inspected by a mechanic I trusted. 18ish months later it died, I had it towed to same shop. My wife was with her and the mechanic asked when the last time the oil was changed. Couple of months ago. Who did the oil change? Shop over by work. Was that your first oil change? Oh no, couple of time before that. At that point he had enough, he directly confronted her, why are you lying? Took her over to the car, showed her the oil filter he put on when he did the prebuy inspection, with the mark he made on it. {sigh}. I know she didn't learn that behavior from her mom or I. I change the oil in our cars, and actually sample each oil change.