Forum Discussion

billtex's avatar
billtex
Explorer II
Apr 02, 2014

Oh no...not more tire/wheel ?'s

Time for new tires this year. Will likely move up in capacity as well from current 265/75R/16 (3415#). So what are the advantages/disadvantages of 285/75R/16 (3750#) vs 19.5”?
Going to 285’s will give me 7500# capacity on the rear axle, which is sufficient for our load. The 19.5” will give even greater (but not necessary) capacity.

Either will require new wheels as well.

• Cost?
• Will either/both require a leveling kit or cutting fender well?
• Some Folks report that 285 are too squishy due to sidewall height?
• Some Folks report the 19.5 are very harsh riding on a ¾ ton and not worth it and have switched back to conventional sizes.
• Some Folks report the 19.5’s are not good in the snow/ice. (Here in New England I need a good winter tire and would like to run one tire all year)

Current tires are 265/75R/16 BFG Commercial TA Traction which have been great in the snow, tread wear has been OK (will get ~ 40k mi-running heavy), sidewalls could be stiffer (see heavy load comment). Truck is 2006 Duramax Crew Cab 4x4 SB.

Would like to hear from those that have been there/done that with SRW trucks.

Thanks, Bill

69 Replies