Forum Discussion
- LIKE2BUILDExplorer
agesilaus wrote:
Frankly as a retired chemist I'd be more likely to believe this if they explained what miracle additive they are using. Otherwise it sounds like marketing BS. DEF is plain and simple 35% Urea
I'm with you, if there was some super special ingredient it would have to be cited in the SDS......and there is no mention of any components in the mixture other than 33% Urea and 67% water. There can be no additives that create the "Advanced System Shield" because by law they would have to appear in the SDS.
The ONLY thing that might make sense is if they have simply reduced impurities in the mixture :h I haven't seen an elemental analysis of DEF deposits, but I suppose it's possible if there are mineral salts present in cheap DEF that they could crystalize and build up over time. Or there could be a reaction with trace metals and the urea that occurs under heat that forms crystals. IF I had to guess I'd say the Platinum product just uses a higher purity water source like double distilled water instead of reverse osmosis water. Or, maybe they use a higher purity urea when making the DEF solution.
The description says "prevents future deposits" so if you already have chunks in your exhaust this new product will not dissolve them.
As for the production of urea, as you stated, it's a synthetic process and is described here: Urea Production Process - agesilausExplorer III
No more DEF than I use in a year's time the small amount of money for the new and improved "Platinum" DEF is nothing and I will begin using it until proven otherwise.
I'd say you have that backwards, I'll begin using when they prove that it works not the other way around. I found plenty of links once I switched to SCR deposits both on Google and YouTube but they were almost all either scientific paers or major industrial users.
I worked at a power plant and we bought technical grade DEF by the tank truck load several times a week. It was 50% Urea the highest concentration that you can get that does not freeze at higher temps.
That was fed into a building sized SCR and that would build up deposits which were removed by steam cleaning.
But that was low purity DEF and the stuff we use is supposed to be higher purity and if it was a problemI would expect to find articles on the diesel truck forums, here, or on the diesel maintenance areas of YouTube but I don't see those.
So it does not seem to be a real problem. - BB_TXNomadIf you take time to read thru the links I posted above, you will see that deposits from DEF into the SCR system is a long known problem. If the liquid atomized particles hit a hot surface and dry before they evaporate they will form deposits. And over time the build up of those deposits lead to problems of possible back pressure. And that would lead to reduced fuel economy. Those of you with chemical backgrounds may understand the whole process from reading the articles.
From the links above there are multiple mechanical attempts being tested to reduce those deposits. Obviously the new Peak DEF doesn't do anything to the mechanical aspects of the system. But somehow manipulating the chemical aspects of the DEF might increase the evaporation rate and reduce the deposits. Obviously a better DEF would be cheaper solution than a mechanical modification to the system.
No more DEF than I use in a year's time the small amount of money for the new and improved "Platinum" DEF is nothing and I will begin using it until proven otherwise. - ACZLExplorer
RobWNY wrote:
My local LOWES has regular Blue DEF for $12.98 and Platinum Blue DEF for $19.98 in the 2.5 Gallon box
Holy smacka-roonies !!!!! Think pump price for DEF last week was $1.99/gal where I get fuel. - agesilausExplorer IIIWalmart has DEF for $7, and it is the same stuff as the $13 DEF and probably the same as the $20 material. And so it would be $13 a bottle more not 'a couple of bucks" almost three times the $7 stuff.
As PT Barnum supposedly said: "There is a sucker born every minute." And that's when the population was much lower the rate is probably one every few seconds these days. Especially with the stupidification of the schools. - RobWNYExplorerMy local LOWES has regular Blue DEF for $12.98 and Platinum Blue DEF for $19.98 in the 2.5 Gallon box
- IdaDExplorer
BB_TX wrote:
Edd505 wrote:
RobWNY wrote:
It sounds good. I'm interested in learning what the cost will be and it would be nice if the shelf life was greater than the 18 months regular Blue DEF provides.
Shelf life? Fill at the truck stop $2.99 a gallon and always fresh, refill as needed.
That you get at the pump is never completely fresh. They just pour the new into the tank on top of the old and it all gets diluted. The old just keeps getting more diluted each time but never completely goes away. So you end up with multiple ages of DEF all mixed together.
Better or worse than the jug? Who can say?
The only places I've seen DEF at the pump are higher volume truck stops so it stands to reason they turn it over pretty quickly, and it would pretty heavily dilute the older stuff I'd think.
When it comes to DEF I'm all about convenience. Since Costco started carrying Peak Blue, that's mostly what I use because I'm there every week. I have no issues with Walmart or Pump DEF, though - it's all the same stuff. - naturistNomad
stickdog wrote:
Come on guys, you have $60, $70G invested in your tow what's $2.00 $3.00 more to protect your investment.
Good arithmetic only if it actually works. If it doesn’t, it is still a waste of good money. And frankly, as a retired chemist, I, too, see zero cause to believe this is anything more than marketing hype. - stickdogExplorerCome on guys, you have $60, $70G invested in your tow what's $2.00 $3.00 more to protect your investment.
- ktmrfsExplorer IIsince def is defined by standards in what it must consist of and only consist of, I find it hard to believe they can or did add anything else.
About Travel Trailer Group
44,029 PostsLatest Activity: Jan 28, 2025