Settle this for Sequoia and 4Runner owners...

Sam, You should just tell them all to get Tesla’s....

memtb wrote:
Yosemite Sam1, I would say that my only concern would be engine rpm, which would have to be at or above the redline before I’d go into panic mode. If the engine braking with downshifts can’t control the speed... it’s time to apply brakes. Probably would be a good time to pull the parachute release, as you may not be in contact with terra- firma! :B memtb

Exactly, don't understand why my friend found it funny in his Tioga Pass near miss. He could be flying in that deep ravine and would not be found in another 10 years or so when no one sees him flying down, lol.

Yosemite Sam1 wrote:

Bedlam wrote:
Most automatics do lock the torque convertor in first gear, so I suspect anyone using that gear for sustained periods of time is building up a lot of heat. If second cannot hold you, you are traveling to fast for the amount weight you are towing.

I would suspect that too. Was not able to follow up whether the trailer is pushing his TV beyond the upper most speed range of the 1st gear, then I would imagine he would get a worst tranny problem than just overheating -- although the group has full trust and confidence with the Toyota/Japanese engineering excellence, loll.

I don't think the transmission is even going in 1st. The engine would be way overspeed in most situations unless you were going super slow.

Most modern transmissions will only downshift as far as the computer deems safe. It wouldn't surprise me if people just slam the lever in 1st thinking that is where the trans is shifting, when really they are in 3rd or second.

Yosemite Sam1, I would say that my only concern would be engine rpm, which would have to be at or above the redline before I’d go into panic mode. If the engine braking with downshifts can’t control the speed... it’s time to apply brakes. Probably would be a good time to pull the parachute release, as you may not be in contact with terra- firma! :B memtb

Bedlam wrote:
Most automatics do lock the torque convertor in first gear, so I suspect anyone using that gear for sustained periods of time is building up a lot of heat. If second cannot hold you, you are traveling to fast for the amount weight you are towing.

I would suspect that too. Was not able to follow up whether the trailer is pushing his TV beyond the upper most speed range of the 1st gear, then I would imagine he would get a worst tranny problem than just overheating -- although the group has full trust and confidence with the Toyota/Japanese engineering excellence, loll.

Most automatics do NOT lock the torque convertor in first gear, so I suspect anyone using that gear for sustained periods of time is building up a lot of heat. If second cannot hold you, you are traveling to fast for the amount weight you are towing.

Yosemite Sam1 wrote:


One question I had is how is the tranny when going at first gear on downhill.

The answer is nothing seems wrong: grinding or over-heating. RPM though is elevated at 3,000+ RPM.

Whatever you're on, I'll take 2!

memtb wrote:

Yosemite Sam1 wrote:

memtb wrote:
Yosemite Sam1, I don’t know how far down it will shift. We’ve never towed with ours, going from OD to 4th was sufficient to slow the vehicle...don’t know if it would continue to downshift when towing! memtb

A friend says he even uses the 1st (lowest gear) to assist the brake having learned a lesson when he burned his brakes while going downhill Eastbound from 9,000 ft above sea level at Tioga Pass.

While I don’t tow with ours, I have never had reservations about manually downshifting an automatic, if I thought it was needed. I was just responding to the questions about the vehicle doing it itself.

In a nearby town with a few steep hills, I often manually downshift to maintain the speed limit....though, I’ve only gone down to 2nd gear. Next time I go to town, I may have to reduce the cruise set-point to 5 mph below posted speed, and observe whether the tranny will continue to downshift to lower gears to maintain speed set-point! Inquiring Minds! memtb

One question I had is how is the tranny when going at first gear on downhill.

The answer is nothing seems wrong: grinding or over-heating. RPM though is elevated at 3,000+ RPM.

Yosemite Sam1 wrote:

memtb wrote:
Yosemite Sam1, I don’t know how far down it will shift. We’ve never towed with ours, going from OD to 4th was sufficient to slow the vehicle...don’t know if it would continue to downshift when towing! memtb

A friend says he even uses the 1st (lowest gear) to assist the brake having learned a lesson when he burned his brakes while going downhill Eastbound from 9,000 ft above sea level at Tioga Pass.

While I don’t tow with ours, I have never had reservations about manually downshifting an automatic, if I thought it was needed. I was just responding to the questions about the vehicle doing it itself.

In a nearby town with a few steep hills, I often manually downshift to maintain the speed limit....though, I’ve only gone down to 2nd gear. Next time I go to town, I may have to reduce the cruise set-point to 5 mph below posted speed, and observe whether the tranny will continue to downshift to lower gears to maintain speed set-point! Inquiring Minds! memtb

memtb wrote:
Yosemite Sam1, I don’t know how far down it will shift. We’ve never towed with ours, going from OD to 4th was sufficient to slow the vehicle...don’t know if it would continue to downshift when towing! memtb

A friend says he even uses the 1st (lowest gear) to assist the brake having learned a lesson when he burned his brakes while going downhill Eastbound from 9,000 ft above sea level at Tioga Pass.