Forum Discussion

MargaretB's avatar
MargaretB
Explorer
Oct 09, 2014

The results of a huge day of searching. Opinions welcome!

Well, we hit six or seven dealers today. These are the top contenders. Some have bells and some have whistles. All would work for us.

Kitchen island models:

We still like the Surveyor Cadet 226RBDS. Similar layouts in the Funfinder F233RBS and the Jayco 24RBD, but we have no idea how they compare in quality. These all have the entertainment center between the bed and the living area, and one of them has the TV on a swivel between the bedroom and living area.

No island but a sizable flared kitchen counter. These have a curtain between the bed and the living area, which makes for a more open feel.

In this category, we really liked the Tracer Ultra Lite 230 - lots that we appreciated about it, especially the "E-Z Tow" wheels, which have more space between them than others we saw.

We also liked the Funfinder F214WSD, the Passport Ultra Lite Grand Touring 220RB, and the Nash 24M.

All of these are in roughly the same dry weight range, between 4500 and 5000, and are priced within a few thousand dollars of each other.

We also loved the Starcraft 244DS but it was listed at more than $10K more than the others, so it's out of our range.

All of these met our criteria - all the sales people nearly cried when I recited the list - of dry weight around 5000#, box about 22' - 23', at least one slide, walk-around queen and no bunks, and fiberglass finish. All are towable by our 2010 Sequoia with the towing package, which is rated at around 9000#. We are being VERY conservative with weight.

None of them has the sofa I wanted or the standard dinette my husband wants, but those are compromises we have to make to hit our budget and other requirements.

So, are there strong opinions pro or con any of these?
  • Jayco is reputed to build a good trailer. Surveyor - we camp with a family who just finished their first season in a new surveyor (albeit a LOT bigger) and seem happy.

    My choice would be the Nash, of if they have that floor plan available in the Arctic Fox line (same manu).

    Good luck.
  • Assuming all these are on dealer lots. I would make another lap and look at things like the cabinets and hardware, how well they slide and/or latch, the colors, the fabrics and whether they look serviceable and can you live with them for several years. Assume all the appliances are pretty much equal. Look at the exterior graphics....I know it sounds silly, but can you live with whatever is on there? Some are just WAY overdone and we couldn't deal with it. Do they all have day/night shades? A very nice feature. I didn't think I'd care for them and would have rather had my mini-blinds back, but LOVE the shades.

    Crawl down and look for the build date on the tires. It's a 4-digit number along the edge of the rim. Something like 2514 would mean they were manufactured the 25th week of 2014. Sometimes it's tough to find and they may have it turned inside, but if you can't find it, ask for someone to do it. You want tires that are as new as possible. Trailer tires die from old age, not wear, in most cases. 4 - 5 years is about max.

    You've really put a lot of work and thought into this and sounds like you've found some good choices. Is the spread for the least expensive to the most expensive worth it and why? Is there one that just calls out to you? IMHO, then that's the one. Good luck and have fun....we'll be ready for a report tomorrow.
  • That's good to know. We didn't get to see the inside because it was sold but it's been recommended, and they're going to call us when more come in so we can actually see it.
  • I looked at many of the same campers as you and I was most impressed with the Nash.