aftermath wrote:
Go with the Ds. You are correct in making sure your rims will handle the tire and the dealer should be able to tell you. My gut reaction is that it will be OK. Someone here will know.
If those Marathons were original in 2008 then you got plenty of use out of them. As you know, the tread isn't the way to measure the life left in a trailer tire. I had a similar situation and changed over to Maxxi LRD and have been happy with them. My marathons came with the trailer and were showing signs of tread separation. Around 2008-2010 Goodyear was moving production around. First it was the USA then China and I think they might be back now but I haven't followed this lately. There were some bad tires out there but I don't think that is much of a concern now.
Whatever tire you get make sure it has a safety margin with weight, keep them pumped up to the sidewall max and watch them closely. Get a tire pressure monitoring system if you can swing it.
We purchased the camper used a year ago this week, they are the original tires that came with the trailer, the original owners only used the trailer for a few short trips in the 6 years they had it. We made several trips last year, I keep a close eye on my tires, I saw a few cracks after our last trip which is enough for me, they're 8 years old and time to be replaced. I saw where Marathons were made here then Canada and now China.
I always check my tire pressures before trips, one of these days a monitoring system might be in order.
I just need some good tires and appreciate all suggestions.