I think my issue is I am expecting the OP to perform a real comparison with real parameters vs. I'm going to try this truck for a week or two and let you know how they compare. In my mind a worthwhile comparison would have to have some wide open full throttle driving. It would include the trucks caring the same load up and down the same steep hills.
But I don't believe the comparison will be apples to apples. Nor will it be very stringent in terms of the same course or even the same demands.
In the end you will have more of an opinion than a comparison.
Again it's the play on words thing, but I was looking forward to a more factual/analytical comparison vs. an opinion that contains no real comparable data.
In the end the OP is right his comparison, his rules, his conclusion.
If it works for him that's all that really matters.
